• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Should I Quit?

What would you do?

  • Quit the cover band.

    Votes: 2 1.7%
  • Quit both bands.

    Votes: 73 62.4%
  • Stay in the original band only, provided a ZERO tolerance for drinking.

    Votes: 5 4.3%
  • Stay in both bands, provided a ZERO tolerance for drinking.

    Votes: 37 31.6%

  • Total voters
    117

FingerDub

Inactive
Jan 8, 2016
2,811
5,919
I just got done with band practice and I am FUMING. The guitarist, (whom I have another band with, more on that later), was drinking and during a part of a song where I was unsure of the change, became belligerent and refused to show me it. Then he stared at me, looking through me and said "*&%# YOU" for no reason at all and said it several times. By this time, the other band members had stopped playing and everything became uncomfortable. I snapped back and the female lead singer stepped in. I felt highly embarrassed. This is a modern cover band and I was having a lot of fun tonight up until it happened. We have only practiced twice including tonight and were making very good progress with almost 20 songs played decent/well. He asked me as a favor to be the bass player for this band and I agreed, with the stipulation that I will only accept paying gigs. I have another cover band covering different material that I do get paid from, so this would have been my 3rd active band.

I also have a 3 piece original band with this guy, and I've been with them for a year and a half. I really like our music and over the last 6 months, we have been writing some awesome new songs, 2 of which are mine and that I'm really proud of. I've really been able to flourish as a bass player in this band and we are about to go into the studio to record a new album with 8 new songs, including my 2. We practiced yesterday and had a great and productive practice, while he was not drinking. I also REALLY like the drummer, not just cause he's bad ass, but because we have become good, genuine friends. He has also stated that the guitarist is a jerk multiple times for several other reasons not mentioned here, and at one time asked me if I would start a new band with him if he quit.

However, he did the exact same thing to me 3 months ago, not to the drummer, and perhaps never would, but to me. But it was worse. More belligerence, angrier demeanor and didn't give a $#%*. That time I walked out of practice, and he again told me to *&$# off, and to not come back as I was leaving, only to heavily apologize the next day. I guess for whatever reason, we don't mix.

I should also mention that I am newly sober, with 2 weeks of sobriety. He knows this. I am finally getting serious about my life and have no time for this crap and simply cannot be around it. I know that I need to be around positive people who lift me up, not active alcoholics starting static with me while drunk. On the other hand, God knows I've wronged other people as well while drinking, and I think that it takes a man to accept an apology from someone and to not hold a grudge. But, I'm not going to be someone's whipping boy. Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me?

I'm not going to act yet, and I'm going to sit on it for a while and think about it, but at this point I'm leaning towards quitting both bands. Not to spite him, but to put my efforts into other good, respectful bandmates. I think I'm good enough to find other good bands. I have the 3rd band, which I enjoy so I would not be bandless. I would really miss the original band and I wouldn't be too happy flushing all that hard work down the toilet, but sometimes difficult decisions have to be made I guess.

The only other thing I can think of would be to accept his apology, but to tell him that I would stick around in one or both of the bands, only if he didn't drink at all. One drop and I'm out. He hasn't treated me that way sober before. The thing I would feel most guilty about would be leaving the drummer.

What would you do? Quit the original band or both? Give him another shot provided he no longer drinks? This sucks for a number of reasons.

I'm going to try to go to bed now, I'll respond to stuff tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
Self preservation is key, as are chances for people.
Obviously drink does him no favours and you chose not to have it in your life.

One more chance, no drink or you walk but support him after if he requires it as non band member if he carries on drinking
 
I think this is a situation you can set an ultimatum in. IF he apologizes, then you can agree to stay so long as he gets his act together and doesn't do it again. Get the drummer and singer (anyone else?) on board as well. Frankly, unless there's something I'm missing, I'm not sure why you're talking about quitting rather than firing him.
 
Getting out of a band or like breaking up with someone is like knocking over a coke machine. You can't do it in one push, you gotta rock it back and forth a few times and THEN it falls over.

It's been my goal for a long time now to reduce the amount of stress in my life. I've even cut out my parents and extended family. The question is, is it worth it? Even Slash got sick of Axl's crap.
 
I don't like to see drinking get out of control in a band. It makes people mess up and it causes conflict when values clash.

I would let things cool off then ask if the drinking can be kept under control. I don't think you can impose your will over his right to choose so if he chooses to continue drinking, you can choose to leave. No other option unless you accept his drinking and reactions while drinking. I wouldn't like stepping away from something I invested time in but if I am committed to a new course in my life, I'd need to find like minded people.

Besides, if the behavior continues, you know it's a going to derail in time.

Good luck and don't put yourself in a place where you are in conflict with your values.
 
I'd get together with the drummer and have a word about forming a new band.....

Then I'd fire him and rage quit! :D....

Seriously OP.....If drinking is a problem with band mates after your recent decision to get sober then maybe you should try to find a booze free band to play with.....Ultimately though....It's a decision that only you can make....

Good luck :thumbsup:
 
Make your feelings known....now. Let your guitarist know, to his face (when sober) that you are considering quitting working with him, and he is 100% why. Give him every reason you can think of, that you don't want to be in a band with him.

If he says, .....".damn dude, I don't want the band to break up....I didn't realize... " then you try to make it work.

If he says " whatever man, you're the one with the problem"..... then quit and don't look back. Take your drummer.




A little anecdote-. My last original band fought through an alcoholic guitarist for years, trying to make it work, making excuses, knowing it effected performances sometimes....because we loved our music so much. We got a bit of label interest, and it put some hyperfocus on the situation. Do I want to be on the side of the road in BFE, with this drunk ******* ragequitting, and then be on the hook to a label for money???


Hell no. I did not. Band broke up, and I haven't been in an original band since. Left a bad bad taste in my mouth.


Learn from that mistake.
 
You are newly sober. To stay that way , you need to keep yourself out of situations that may tempt you.
+ 1.

When I cleaned up my mess, I told the band that they could replace me or they could separate partying from practicing. It worked out well.

I will quit any band that play covers.
Some of us like to make money.