peaveyuser said:
Honestly that is probably one of the most f@$king stupid things i've ever heard on a forum. If your bass drops in a gig bag chances are something is going to happen unless your in a heavily padded room. And a suede gig bag, come on a gig bag is for going outside and going place to place, ever thought what will happen when it rains while your waiting for the bus or walking to your car. Gig bags are usually light transportation for when you have a long trip and don't want the weight of a hardshell. Also if you did have a 8000$ bass you'd have to be pretty dam stupid to use anything but a hardshell because if there is always a risk of something happening with a gig bag.
Well that's a good way to start a conversation...
I'm not doing any tests, but here's my logic:
If you have a nice, padded leather gigbag, and it falls over. The padding of the bag will absorb a good portion of the shock.
If a hard-case falls over, its going to hit the ground with a harder initial impact (due to the hard exterior), and the interior of the case will absorb the shock, with your bass pressing against whatever the case is lined with.
Hard-cases are heavier too, so they're going to hit the ground with more force.
I'm not saying that if your bass falls, a gigbag will protect it better than a gigbag, and I don't really know. But I would guess that either one would protect it about the same.
I'm currently anxiously awaiting two custom leather gigbags and I plan to carry my $3,000 basses in them almost exclusively. In case you didn't know, leather is waterproof
I had my semi-hard shell case in some heavy rain for a while just last week (Seattle

), and it deformed/softened some of the foam around the exterior
Of course, if you're going to be throwing your bass into the back of a truck with a bunch of other gear, or checking it onto an airplane...etc. Any situation where there is obvious risk of other objects ramming into it, then yeah. By all means, get a nice flight case. But for day to day use, I'll stick to slinging a nice gigbag over my shoulder.
Here's a basic outline of my day:
Leave house with bass in gigbag
Get on the bus (usually in the hard-case my bass gets the inner seat next to me all to itself, but in a gigbag I could probably keep it in front of me)
Arrive at school (going to Cornish, studying music)
Put my bass in "the Bass closet". A locked room with individual cubby slots for each bass.
Go to classes
Get my bass for Ensemble/rehearsals...etc.
Play for a while...
When that's done, bass goes right back into the gigbag and then right back into the bass closet.
More classes...
Go home with the bass, on the bus again.
Sounds pretty risky, eh? Why do I need a Hard Shell Case again?
