• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Stick around? Walk Away? or Say Something?

1w58.jpg
.
 
...Your guitarist friend thinks this other dude is a better bassist than you because he plays bass like a guitarist. He doesn't mind telling you this even though it obviously could be taken as an insult by you...

Never understood how complementing the skill of bassist 1 to bassist 2 would be thought of as an insult by bassist 2.

If your ego is so fragile you take complements of other players skill are an insult to yours, you certainly don't need to be anywhere near the music business.

Skill is a relative thing and an opinion of skill is such a subjective thing. Thinking of said opinion as some kind of insult is not just silly, it's guaranteed to keep you in a constant state of butthurtedness if you hang around your typical musician(s).

As far as that goes, if you are not able to hear a compliment of another as anything but an insult to you, you got way more troubles than your skill as a musician.
 
Never understood how complementing the skill of bassist 1 to bassist 2 would be thought of as an insult by bassist 2.

If your ego is so fragile you take complements of other players skill are an insult to yours, you certainly don't need to be anywhere near the music business.

Skill is a relative thing and an opinion of skill is such a subjective thing. Thinking of said opinion as some kind of insult is not just silly, it's guaranteed to keep you in a constant state of butthurtedness if you hang around your typical musician(s).

As far as that goes, if you are not able to hear a compliment of another as anything but an insult to you, you got way more troubles than your skill as a musician.


You're right. It's very tough. But music is the only thing i got between holding on to hope and slitting my wrists. Whats worse is I cannot even accept a compliment myself. I immediately mentally discredit the person giving me the compliment. But every compliment another person receives I see as genuine and well deserved. It is like living in a mine field of things that hurt my feelings. I think my low self-esteem is a defense mechanism of sorts. I dunno, it's twisted. Like I expect to be hurt or I deserve it anyway. But it's ok though. I'm still trying. I'm in therapy, and I got the support of my TB brothers who understand me.
 
You're right. It's very tough. But music is the only thing i got between holding on to hope and slitting my wrists. Whats worse is I cannot even accept a compliment myself. I immediately mentally discredit the person giving me the compliment. But every compliment another person receives I see as genuine and well deserved. It is like living in a mine field of things that hurt my feelings. I think my low self-esteem is a defense mechanism of sorts. I dunno, it's twisted. Like I expect to be hurt or I deserve it anyway. But it's ok though. I'm still trying. I'm in therapy, and I got the support of my TB brothers who understand me.

Www.personalitypages.com is a great place to begin understanding who YOU are for a whopping $5.00

You are who you are party by training from your parents, partly by your own chemistry and partly thru birth order and siblings.

I encourage you to try and understand yourself a little more to better deal with situations like your current one.

Beyond that, if you have a hard time with a personal approach consider a 'late night email' after one of these sessions. Spend a lot of time drafting it and reading it over several days, then send one night after practice. Let him know you don't want to raise the issue in front of his friend but you are starting to feel like a 'third wheel' and don't really know where you stand in all this. Then outright ask if you should just bow out (to which he probably says no) or if he can agree your practice times with him are the two of you and he can play (with his gearless buddy) other times. Tell him practice only works when one is actually playing, not watching someone else.
A
 
Never understood how complementing the skill of bassist 1 to bassist 2 would be thought of as an insult by bassist 2.

If your ego is so fragile you take complements of other players skill are an insult to yours, you certainly don't need to be anywhere near the music business.

Skill is a relative thing and an opinion of skill is such a subjective thing. Thinking of said opinion as some kind of insult is not just silly, it's guaranteed to keep you in a constant state of butthurtedness if you hang around your typical musician(s).

As far as that goes, if you are not able to hear a compliment of another as anything but an insult to you, you got way more troubles than your skill as a musician.
In the OP, it states that the guitarist said "yeah you're good, but he's just a bass phenomenon."
If someone said that to me while the so-called phenomenon had to use my gear, I would be offended. It's saying that the OP is only useful in that the other guy has his gear to use. I would be out of there fast enough to make that guitarist's head spin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tennesseemick
...In the OP, it states that the guitarist said "yeah you're good, but he's just a bass phenomenon."
If someone said that to me while the so-called phenomenon had to use my gear, I would be offended. It's saying that the OP is only useful in that the other guy has his gear to use...

Actually, all it's saying is some guy thinks one bassist is more skilled than the other.

It's an opinion, no more no less. Quit reading something into it that's not there.
 
Actually, all it's saying is some guy thinks one bassist is more skilled than the other.

It's an opinion, no more no less. Quit reading something into it that's not there.

Nah I think Hobo is spot on here. Think about it, this "phenom" bass player with no groove, is the guitarists good friend. Good enough that he happily offered up equipment for him to come jam on that's not even his. Guitarist is an ass at right there. But it gets better.

Guitarist man thinks his good friend "phenom" bass player is actually good even though he can't groove? What?! Sounds like a failed guitarist trying to score a gig on bass with all those supposed soloing chops. A bass player that can't just sit back and groove, lock in with that kick drum is completely worthless. The fact that guitarist man think's he's a "phenom" is telling. Tells me to beat feet the hell out of there and find a real project.