Keep the SR5, I got a MIM jazz 5 as a backup years ago. So as others said save for a used jazz or whatever but keep the stingray.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Stingray 5 as only bass
- Thread starter Jroc07
- Start date
-
- Tags
- stingray stingray 5
A Stingray 4 was my only bass for over a decade. Heck, you're one string up on me there!
I don't understand this idea of one bass.
I love the idea, there's a zen like simplicity to having just one bass that you use for everything. Alas, I've tried to embrace bass minimalism before but it just never works out.
Agree with there not much difference in tone, but you do need to be aware of the gage of the higher 4 strings with 5 string sets.
I second this suggestion!
IMO the SR5 is a great bass, and I very much regret selling the one I used to own. Finding a nice used Jazz Bass for not a lot of money is pretty easy.
I'd also consider a used StingRay.
I bought an SR5 new in Dec 1992. I still have it; it's not my main player anymore due to the weight, but I've played just about every gig you could reasonably imagine on it, from your typical blues/rock/country bar band stuff, contemporary church music, jazz standards out of a Fake Book, even sat in with a couple of bluegrass bands with it.
Gotta say after 20 years, I never got comfortable slapping on it. Not for lack of trying, either. These days I'm mostly playing a Lakland 5; the wider string spacing makes slapping a lot easier.
Personally, I would hang on to the SR5 and save for whatever 4 string floats your boat.
Gotta say after 20 years, I never got comfortable slapping on it. Not for lack of trying, either. These days I'm mostly playing a Lakland 5; the wider string spacing makes slapping a lot easier.
Personally, I would hang on to the SR5 and save for whatever 4 string floats your boat.
This is the problem when you only have one bass. If you get a great jazz 4 will it be for a time when you miss the 5 string? I say keep the 5 which you like and save for the 4... This way you won't have that problem. Going back and forth could be expensive in the long run.
I think your Stingray 5 is the better bass.
If you insist on having one bass, trade for a Stingray 4 and add a Hipshot D-tuner and maybe an octave pedal.
But I think everyone needs at least 2 basses. So why not do the above and add something like a Sire V3 5 string Jazz for backup and when you need those extra notes?
Or keep your Stingray5 and buy a used USA SUB 4 . That way you’ll have a 4 and a 5 string Stingray .
Point is it doesn’t cost a lot of money to get a good bass these days .
If you insist on having one bass, trade for a Stingray 4 and add a Hipshot D-tuner and maybe an octave pedal.
But I think everyone needs at least 2 basses. So why not do the above and add something like a Sire V3 5 string Jazz for backup and when you need those extra notes?
Or keep your Stingray5 and buy a used USA SUB 4 . That way you’ll have a 4 and a 5 string Stingray .
Point is it doesn’t cost a lot of money to get a good bass these days .
I think what’s missing here (at least from what I’ve read) is whether or not you are using the B string much now. If you are playing styles where getting below E is important, you’ll miss the five. But if it’s all rock in standard keys, a 4 is likely fine. I agre with the others though, and think you should just save up for a used Jazz of some sort
I’m not sure I understand. I use the same gauge strings on my 5 and 4 strings; GHS boomers medium light, both 5 and 4 string sets are 45 65 80 100 (126). The only difference in gauges is the extra B-string.
Last edited:
Yes, Four extra fretted notes plus One open string note.
IMO if anyone thinks a 5 string bass is just about the extra notes below E they haven't understood much about 5 string basses.
To the OP, I'm not sure why you want to get rid of bass you have liked playing for so long on a whim that a Jazz might play and sound better.
IMO it would be better to get a Jazz and play it for awhile, to see what you think. Only then would I consider selling my SR5.
To the OP, I'm not sure why you want to get rid of bass you have liked playing for so long on a whim that a Jazz might play and sound better.
IMO it would be better to get a Jazz and play it for awhile, to see what you think. Only then would I consider selling my SR5.
As a fan of both Fender and EBMM, and someone who has owned and played LOTS of each, we'll have to agree to disagree on that... I will agree that EBMM's quality is definitely more consistent, though - some of the best in the biz, IMO/IME...
