Hey guys, do any of you use noise gate pedals? If so, what? Pros/cons?
i hate them. i find they totally kill the heaviness. i like sustain and feedback, it makes the music just ooze.
as a gated effect they have their uses but as a utility pedal to control noise/feedback i prefer to just use a mute switch
I go the other route. I like my rig dead quiet when I'm not playing, and not blaring feedback or anything. I have 2 in my chain - 1 after dirt and 1 in the loop to kill any noise from the preamp. The second one is also before my delay, so my delays aren't cut short.
I find that using them subtly, so they don't chomp down on the signal too early is my preference. I don't like gated sounding effects, though.
I currently use an MXR SmartGate and an ISP Decimator (the old one, I think). Both work fine, are very simple, and allow notes to sustain without killing them too early (unless you set them to). Edit - I could likely just use the one in my FX loop, but on occasion my B3K just seems to run hotter and need a gate to avoid annoying hiss. The ISP solves that. Also, if I ever run one of my other amps without a loop, I don't have to refigure my board much. Just run the out of the ISP to my HPF and delay that are typically in the loop.
For my cheaper practice boards I use the DOD Gate/Loop, which is better as a Gate than a loop, as it doesn't have the sensitivity of the others. I've also used a Boss NS-2 with my old HM-2 in my guitar rig. The "x" configuration works best to kill unwanted noise, and still keep attack.
Hope this helps!
Edit: As for pros and cons, the biggest con for me is having to adjust the gain levels of my pedals, and then consequently the sensitivity of my gates. Since I often have to adjust volume between solo practice and rehearsal, this can get a bit much at times. I know now where to set the gates for each scenario, but it can take a bit to figure out, and sometimes I forget and my rig sounds off until I fix it. This is more of an issue with my guitar rig, as I use the clean channel only and the dirt levels must be constantly adjusted when the amp needs to be louder (only a single pre/vol on that channel). On my bass rig, I keep the pre volume pretty constant, so the tone of distortion and volume up until this portion is identical, and tweak the power amp volume to whatever I need. That way, I only ever have to mess with the single knob on my SmartGate (and even then rarely) once I have the volume where I need it on the amp.