not to derail the thread but i just realized that Robert has been in Metallica longer than Jason was...that's F'd up
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
It is becoming a "thing" at some venues. Now, in certain states, they are also being asked to collect sales tax.Ive never had a venue ask for a cut of my merch. Id be telling them to pound sand. I love playing music but not enough to do that just to play. I like our basement just fine.
Just another example of someone else being a tick on the back of musicians. We do all the work, they get the money. It is capitalism to such an F'ed up extent that it has wrapped it's way back into some kind of reverse socialism. The serfs are paying the lords for the honor to work their land.Oh F^c%... I flipped when I found out about merch cuts. Its unbelievable, especially when you're getting low-balled on the guarantee! We won't take that sh!t locally, but it's par for the course for most theaters/medium venue shows. When we go on the road, the merch cut % is written into the contract. It's the most disgusting thing you can do to band in the modern era, as we've been basically been reduced to traveling t-shirt salesmen as it is. There are a bunch of strategies for getting away with giving reduced cuts, but places like Live Nation venues make you give them an inventory before and after the show or count you in and out themselves! ***! I can live with a merch cut if the venue sells for you, which sometimes we're forced to do... but once, Live Nation sent the band a tax form claiming they paid us for the merch of ours that they sold. Can you believe that sh|t?!?! They took 20% of our money and then told the IRS they paid us so they wouldn't have to pay taxes on it... but the band who just got paid $100 guarantee, does? Its a f^(king disgusting part of this already fairly repulsive industry and I don't think Ill ever get used to it.
And they still have yet to use him to his fullest extent. He is a very talented musician, but is being hobbled creatively but the Metallica 'brand.' He gets paid pretty good, so I guess he probably doesn't care.not to derail the thread but i just realized that Robert has been in Metallica longer than Jason was...that's F'd up
I remember when I found out, as a fan, that the money I was gladly forking over at the merch table wasn't 100% going to the band. Major *** moment. I thought I was utilizing the one method, short of just slipping them a $20 bill, that a label, venue, promoter, etc couldn't touch. Depressing.Oh F^c%... I flipped when I found out about merch cuts. Its unbelievable, especially when you're getting low-balled on the guarantee! We won't take that sh!t locally, but it's par for the course for most theaters/medium venue shows. When we go on the road, the merch cut % is written into the contract. It's the most disgusting thing you can do to band in the modern era, as we've been basically been reduced to traveling t-shirt salesmen as it is. There are a bunch of strategies for getting away with giving reduced cuts, but places like Live Nation venues make you give them an inventory before and after the show or count you in and out themselves! ***! I can live with a merch cut if the venue sells for you, which sometimes we're forced to do... but once, Live Nation sent the band a tax form claiming they paid us for the merch of ours that they sold. Can you believe that sh|t?!?! They took 20% of our money and then told the IRS they paid us so they wouldn't have to pay taxes on it... but the band who just got paid $100 guarantee, does? Its a f^(king disgusting part of this already fairly repulsive industry and I don't think Ill ever get used to it.
Daaaang. That’s really depressing for some reason.not to derail the thread but i just realized that Robert has been in Metallica longer than Jason was...that's F'd up
Well, it depends on the tour and venue, a lot. So don't stop supporting the bands, brother.I remember when I found out, as a fan, that the money I was gladly forking over at the merch table wasn't 100% going to the band. Major *** moment. I thought I was utilizing the one method, short of just slipping them a $20 bill, that a label, venue, promoter, etc couldn't touch. Depressing.
Oh I still buy sh*t at the merch table, it is just depressing that depending on the venue/tour, that the band still has someone's hand in the cookie jar.Well, it depends on the tour and venue, a lot. So don't stop supporting the bands, brother.
If its not a tour with a biggish band, there's a good chance there is no cut. Some of the biggish bands even insist they leave the support bands alone... that's nice. In most non AEG, Live Nation, or Canadian venues there is a reasonably good chance there isn't one, and a better chance that, if there is, the band will not be paying the full cut. There are some proven inventory scams and there is also just folks who will buy a reasonable lie. We've done well over $500 in merch and give them 20 bucks. If they ask for a record, we'll use electronic sales because that's all they can prove if they don't count in or out. Most people are super cool about it, honestly. Some don't even bother to collect even if its in the contract.
But the idea is still F**ked.
Well, it depends on the tour and venue, a lot. So don't stop supporting the bands, brother.
If its not a tour with a biggish band, there's a good chance there is no cut. Some of the biggish bands even insist they leave the support bands alone... that's nice. In most non AEG, Live Nation, or Canadian venues there is a reasonably good chance there isn't one, and a better chance that, if there is, the band will not be paying the full cut. There are some proven inventory scams and there is also just folks who will buy a reasonable lie. We've done well over $500 in merch and give them 20 bucks. If they ask for a record, we'll use electronic sales because that's all they can prove if they don't count in or out. Most people are super cool about it, honestly. Some don't even bother to collect even if its in the contract.
But the idea is still F**ked.
[Gets on soapbox]Yeah i wouldnt stop supporting bands, but as the guy who handles most of our merch stuff it really rubs me the wrong way. Where are they when im paying my money getting my shirts printed to be taking a cut of my already thin margins. Makes me mad and im not even dealing with it.
I remember when I found out, as a fan, that the money I was gladly forking over at the merch table wasn't 100% going to the band. Major *** moment. I thought I was utilizing the one method, short of just slipping them a $20 bill, that a label, venue, promoter, etc couldn't touch. Depressing.
Cool. Who's in Sunn now, is Attila still singing? I got my ticket for when they swing into Detroit next month. Then 2 days later, Electric Wizard.Saw Sunn on Sunday. Puce Mary was the opening act. Great stuff, some kinda dark ambient meets noise. Had an apocalyptic vibe to it, which is totally my jam.
Honestly, I have no idea who actually was on stage. 5 people in black robes was all I saw. I have really bad eyesight and sat maybe 40 meters away. No one was singing that night - but there was a trombone solo piece. That was pretty badass.Cool. Who's in Sunn now, is Attila still singing? I got my ticket for when they swing into Detroit next month. Then 2 days later, Electric Wizard.
Thx. It seems like the new record is moving away from vox, which is cool by me. Looking forward to seeing them as it'll be the first time.Honestly, I have no idea who actually was on stage. 5 people in black robes was all I saw. I have really bad eyesight and sat maybe 40 meters away. No one was singing that night - but there was a trombone solo piece. That was pretty badass.
When you get into one these groups, there's only a few ways to get out. . .Apropos of nothing, does anyone else think it is weird that Electric Wizard's song "Barbarian" starts off with someone saying "the wizard"? Shouldn't it be something related to barbarians? F'ing stoners man, I swear.
It's quite an experience, especially a physical one. I recommend hearing protection, seriously. Deafeningly loud.Thx. It seems like the new record is moving away from vox, which is cool by me. Looking forward to seeing them as it'll be the first time.
I'm hoping for mental institutions myself.When you get into one these groups, there's only a few ways to get out. . .