• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Suddenly undecided as to which Precision I should buy

Other than my 1958 Precision the best playing and sounding P-bass I've ever laid hands on was my 2010 Road Worn Precision. Under 8 lbs, resonant, almost indistinguishable from the real '58.

You should be able to find one used for 700-900 used.

If the relic'd thing is a showstopper for you, well, so be it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bmac314
I always say go for the brand thats been around the longest for two reasons. First, they are tried and true and usually of good quality/build. Second, if you need a replacement, its easy to find and replace. Fender meets these traits. The short and skinny is, you cant go wrong with a Fender. Simple as that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Papalampraina
Other than my 1958 Precision the best playing and sounding P-bass I've ever laid hands on was my 2010 Road Worn Precision. Under 8 lbs, resonant, almost indistinguishable from the real '58.

You should be able to find one used for 700-900 used.

If the relic'd thing is a showstopper for you, well, so be it.


I have one of those and it's truly great; one of the best P basses I've ever owned. I did however replace its neck with an all rosewood, steel reinforced Warmoth neck because I found the stock neck to be too thin, front to back.
 
I see. However an actual '63 WOULD be 1.75" at the nut, yes?
The current '63 reissue is 1.74" at the nut.

Presumably the American Professional's neck profile is c-shaped and that is what makes it '63-like.
Gets confusing how Fender uses all their own terminology so loosely.
Yes, the "1963 C Profile" has to do with the actual profile and not about the nut. They are keeping the same nut width though as with the Standards and the Deluxes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Son of Wobble
Yes, the "1963 C Profile" has to do with the actual profile and not about the nut. They are keeping the same nut width though as with the Standards and the Deluxes.

Well, I guess I now I need to try one seeing as that combo of nut size and profile could be THE new SWEET spot.

Like I need another P-bass!

Trio.png
20151226_153026.jpg
62-a-2.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lowendtech
I went the Lakland route a while back with a 44-64 and came to the conclusion that if I wanted a Fender, I should have just got a Fender. My MIM Classic 50's P that I throught would be easily replaced by the Lakland just going by the hype, was superior in just about every way imaginable and that's ignoring the different specs. There was nothing about the bass in my mind that put it on the level of an AmStd, in fact I was kind of let down upon realizing my MIM was put together just as well and was an overall better player. I know that my experience doesn't reflect the majority here, but that's my experience. I wound up selling it and grabbing another Classic P. What I will say though is that Lakland is a great company that cares about its customers. Mine came from Bass Central with electronics that were dead on arrival and a case with a broken latch. John P paid shipping to and from Chicago and replaced the case (which was a $120 up charge). Unfortunately the bass came back still not working and he paid the tab to have my local guy do it again, which I appreciated. I've since learned how to do my own electronic work, so that's something I'd now overlook if the bass was right for me otherwise.
I sold my Am P and kept my MIM P bass because it was a much better player. Don't always consider the more expensive to a bass.
 
I sold my Am P and kept my MIM P bass because it was a much better player. Don't always consider the more expensive to a bass.

It was a consideration and I did expect it to be at least as good with regards to quality, as that's exactly what it's proponents hype it up to be here on TB. Worth noting it was the last time I bought anything based on TB praise and it was a valuable lesson, as I learned to appraise based on facts and the specs that suited me as opposed to just chugging kool-aid.
 
I have a Fender American Standard and a Lakland Skyline. They are both really nice basses; I don't think you could go wrong with either one. A direct comparison is a bit of an apples/oranges deal in my case, as the Fender is a Precision (bought used) and the Lakland is a fretless Jazz (bought new).

The Lakland played great out of the box, and to this day I've never felt the need to adjust any part of it. Then again, I think I'm far more picky with fretted basses. I always seem to struggle to find the balance between for a nice low enough to be comfortable but high enough to let me pluck hard without too much buzz.

The Fender I've adjusted both the neck and action (but it was used so the previous owner may have just had a different preference), and the nut had a terrible rattle in the A and G string slots. I've repaired it on the cheap by shoring up the slots with some elmer's glue, but I'd definitely replace the nut if I gigged or recorded. If I'd bought it new I'd have exchanged it, but I feel that I got a really good deal on a like-new instrument so I don't mind.
 
I've had (and have) a lot of nice P's. There are a ton of great ones out there. Along with several folks who have already made the suggestion, I would buy used right here on TB. Great bang for the buck, and a lot of nice ones available almost all the time.

The Classic '50s are fantastic, but you might not care for the wider neck. Never bothered me; but given my "druthers", I prefer the 1.625" nut width. A used American Standard would also do you well. And don't discount the American Specials. I have one of those (Honeyburst), and it has one of the sweetest necks I've ever had on a Precision. Light-weight, too!
 
  • Like
Reactions: ShirazBop
Pick up a pre-owned American Standard P here on Talkbass,... You should be able to find a great one in the 8 to 9 hundred range,...you will not be disappointed....

I'm playing 3 MIA P5's, my first acquired 2011 and 2 recently (from the same TB'er) 2015's. Each under 900,.. excellent near new condition,... Each one has a slightly different character but each are Top Notch in Fit Finish, tone and playability....

Good luck!
 
Last edited: