Gentlemen, you're both correct! You can have it one way, the other way, both ways, or neither way. I do feel a bass player can go sans pedals and be successful if that particular tone works within the framework of music they're playing. At the same time, correctly utilizing pedals, whether a few or millions, create a tonal pallet that is always within a leg's length of use. It all comes down to the individual and what they wish to use to communicate with.
I myself was a strictly no-pedals player, or use a modeling amp if I felt creative. Then I bought my model-less Terror Bass, loved its tone but felt I could bring more out with a dash of seasoning, and I was right. A bit of chorus added at the right time met what I had in my mind.
The other option you'd have is to buy an inexpensive multi-effects pedal, like a Zoom B1 Four (costs one Benjamin), you can get a decent sampling of numerous sounds without all the cords, cables, and aspirin needed to figure out how to hook it all up! run your bass into the FX pedal, run the pedal to the front end of your combo, and play...done! I have the previous Zoom pedal and use it when I want something I don't have as a separate pedal like a bass synth. Nope, it's not perfect, but fun to mess with and a hoot when I find what I wanted.
So, live in peace fellas. You can both lead productive lives as keepers of the low, whether you do it with or without pedals!
I yield my remaining time if I haven't already used them up!![]()
Agreed @iagtrplyr Hope I didn't come off as combative. I apologize if I did. It's all good. You are spot on in what you say here. I too appreciate what a compressor or chorus can do for a bass. To each his own. But he did ask the question so..... (where are those damm smiley faces when you need one?!)



