@projectapollo Thanks! I have the Tone Hammer which I also use a lot for silent practice, both with the AGS on and off depending on what I’m doing. I’ve been gassing for an Oracle or Noble, probably from reading threads like this, but the TH / Caveman combo is an intriguing option.
Have you done any comparisons between the Caveman, Oracle, or P15 and the TH with the AGS off?
Yes I did include the Tone Hammer DI in my trials with the AGS off. It's a pretty darn good clean EQ/DI if you use modest amounts of EQ gain. Dialing up the bass and mids gain pretty high and things get boomy or sterile. Even more so on the Studio One. The Trickfish Minnow EQ is tuned better and more useable across the range of the controls. But for mild EQ adjustments, the THDI is an excellent choice. It will still be my gig bag back-up since it's phantom powered and ready to go and gets the job done, AGS on or off.
So, I moved the Caveman along, mostly because of the size and need to pair an EQ device with it and limited board space. If I'm going to do the Janek thing and set the Caveman adjacent to the board on the floor, I would prefer the P15 in that tag-along free-roaming role. I did like the inherent tone of the Caveman and hope we see reports that the Mantle gets that vibe. The Mantle is attractive in features/components, unattractive in footprint and price. Eager to hear more analysis.
I have the Broughton P15 listed for sale, but don't want it to sell. Every time I come back to it, it makes me smile. I am content with it, but keep thinking it's a bit of a pain to set-up at 6am call time on Sunday mornings in a 1200 person worship center with FOH and Monitor Engineers running the show and wanting to keep my signal chain as simple and issue free as possible. I'm getting more comfortable with that idea, however. I can definitely see some chill weeks where my P bass with flats or my Serek short scale plugged direct into the P15 and to FOH will be ideal and simple. The last time I showed up with new "experimental" gear, the monitor engineer was gracious and took a few minutes to A/B things and provide his recommendation. He quickly chose the DCX Bass over the Origin Bassrig Fifteen, to my surprise. We tried cab sim on and off. DCX got the call.
So, my current postulated board line up features the DCX Bass first in the chain for touch sensitive lovely saturation with the compact board plugged into P15 as the pre/DI for final polishing EQ and tube (warmth, harmonics, shine, punch, whatever it is doing it sounds good). If I don't use the P15 on a given week, I will go with a Radial passive JDI or active RNDI - and use more generous EQ from the DCX.