• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Why is it called "bolt on neck" when they all use...

I pledge to use the term "Screw-on" neck from now on to describe these the of electric bass and bass

  • Screw-on neck, yes, sign me up.

    Votes: 16 7.6%
  • Bolt-on sounds better, even though they are screws..

    Votes: 99 46.9%
  • What's the difference again between a screw and a bolt?

    Votes: 12 5.7%
  • Less "talk bass" more "play bass".

    Votes: 84 39.8%

  • Total voters
    211
Realistically, even in the photo posted by the OP, all of those are screws. What we call 'Bolts' are 'Hex Head Cap Screws'
McMaster.png

Source: I drink and I know things.
 
  • Like
Reactions: longfinger
It seems by this definition that I can magically turn a bolt into a screw simply by changing which end of the two pieces I'm holding fixed. I'm sure someone meant well, but this smells of a convenience definition which people are taking a little too seriously.

The definition of a bolted connection refers to both the male and female parts of the fastener not being fixed to the parts to be fastened.

If you weld the nut to one of the fastened parts and turn the male fastener to tighten it, a bolt becomes a screw because of the application.

The fastener did not change, the use defines the term to describe it.

In engineering, we try to use precise terminology so everyone understands things the same way.

My granddaughter might see a moth and call it a pretty butterfly. An entomologist, (and I, if I know the difference) will correct her. Her grandmother will agree it's a pretty butterfly. Sorry, I just can't help myself.
 
Last edited:
Why is it called "bolt on neck" when all these types of builds have screws?

http://www.dailycivil.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/bolt-vs-screw.jpg1_.jpg1_.jpg

C'mon people. We know the difference between screws and bolts that require nuts to fasten. Anyone want to take part in the new social movement to call these instruments "screw on necks"?

Rallies? Marches?
Machine "screws" have "machine threads". Lag bolts are still bolts even though they don't require a nut or threaded insert or Tee nut.
 
We ought to be discussing the difference between C# and Db (they are spelled different on the musical staff but not on the tab sheet). not the differences between screws and bolts. This is suppose to be music instrument forum, not a freshman engineering drafting class. If you have or have had registered engineering status, I'm all ears like a jack rabbit. (EIT or FE status would also be acceptable). otherwise, let us stick to the music business. (Ok, I have seen tuned bolts used like bells, and have seen an all metal merrimba, but that discussion hasn't been part of this thread. )
 
The definition of a bolted connection refers to both the male and female parts of the fastener not being fixed to the parts to be fastened.

If you weld the nut to one of the fastened parts and turn the male fastener to tighten it, a bolt becomes a screw because of the application.

The fastener did not change, the use defines the term to describe it.

In engineering, we try to use precise terminology so everyone understands things the same way. Common language can lead us into imprecise terminology that everyone understands, but is actually not correct.

My granddaughter might see a moth and call it a pretty butterfly. An entomologist, (and I, if I know the difference) will correct her. Her grandmother will agree it's a pretty butterfly. Sorry, I just can't help myself.

The terminology isn't at all precise if it names an object differently depending on what happens to a different object. In your analogy that would be like insisting that butterflies only land on plants growing in the ground, but if it lands on a plant in a pot, it is more precise to call it a 'hiftylump' and insisting everyone conform.

B>
 
I agree.

I just go by what the experts and accepted authorities who came before us, (and are way smarter than I am) have defined as the correct terminology.

(Actually there is logic to the terminology, but I'm about to have a little, (more) Irish whiskey, and don't want to get into any arguments tonight).
 
Last edited:
I agree.
I just go by what the experts and accepted authorities who came before us have defined as the correct terminology.

(Actually there is logic to the terminology, but I'm about to have a little Irish whiskey, and don't want to get into any arguments tonight).

Those people weren't so clear on planets, thought Venus was two different stars, defined the primary charge carrier as negative and a bunch of other dumb things. Tradition isn't a great defence.

The terminology defines an application, not an object.

B>