• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

why isnt there a J.Jamerson sig.bass

There's no James Jamerson signature bass because it'd be unplayable. No one (as far as I know) has a stock of 20+ year old thick flatwounds and having the action as high as JJ did would make these Precisions unplayable for most of us. And as others have mentioned, it'd just be a 62 AVRI with a special edition neck plate and nothing more.
 
This thread has been very interesting, thanks to those who contributed to the enjoyment of reading it.

I always thought Jamerson's P bass is too generic, it's one of the few styles/colours they offered back then and he didn't modify it in any way that would be playable by others. I'm kind of glad there isn't 'one just for the sake of it' in his name.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kukulkan61
This thread has been very interesting, thanks to those who contributed to the enjoyment of reading it.

I always thought Jamerson's P bass is too generic, it's one of the few styles/colours they offered back then and he didn't modify it in any way that would be playable by others. I'm kind of glad there isn't 'one just for the sake of it' in his name.

And the Dee Dee Ramone bass is any less generic?
 
Yes, one was already done in the early 90's.
But c'mon, just like many "sig" basses it was just a bone stock Fender. Yes I do dislike sigs.

I agree with this guy, though I don't completely dislike sigs, a lot of them are basically a P or J-bass with a name slapped onto them. When they're different though, like the Marcus Miller, Mark Hoppus (don't like blink 182, being more of a hardcore punk fan, but they're good at what they do and his bass is a cool idea) or the old Stu Hamm Fender signature were actually pretty unique
 
And the Dee Dee Ramone bass is any less generic?
Well I've got a bit of a dour viewpoint on these sig/tribute instruments. May, Gilmour, Clapton, etc have all made/modified their instruments so it's something entirely different than a stock instrument. I endorse giving us the options that these and others have come up with.

There haven't been THAT many basses that are so drastically far from stock. It IS kind of insulting that Geezer, DeeDee, and others have sig instruments that are almost bone stock. At least Harris's has his sig Rotos strung on it. I get the Sting sig P because it's unique.

I guess this was a rant. Sorry?