I'm starting to believe this as well now that I'm on my 2nd short scale. With my current one I have to seriously cut the lows otherwise it's too much. With the last one I thought it was a fluke, but now I'm a believer
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Why would anyone play a bass longer than 30" scale?
- Thread starter MakoMan
- Start date
I'm starting to believe this as well now that I'm on my 2nd short scale. With my current one I have to seriously cut the lows otherwise it's too much. With the last one I thought it was a fluke, but now I'm a believer
View attachment 3231848 View attachment 3231849 View attachment 3231850 It's very simple. They don't make these in 30' scale. And, being a lefty, when I was in a band, whacking somebody in the head was never a problem, either...
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought that in the 60's Tbird basses were in fact 30" like the EBO basses, and the Ricks are medium scale. Either way, I love your collection there
Ive been eyeballing a few Kramer's like that at the sunset GC(they have 4 of them, a few are amazing)
D
Deleted member 165050
Guest
I dare the OP to repeat this thread over on the DB forum
If we just "leave it there" then there would not be much point in most of the threads on this forum
i play 35" scale...better sustain, fuller sound...
The first bass I bought was a 30" scale, because of the basses I tried at that time, it felt right to me. That bass just turned 40 years old and I still play it.
I also play a 20.375" scale (U-Bass) and a 35" scale (5-string), and they all feel right to me, just different than each other, and I like the sound of each.
I've never even owned a 34" bass.
So my question would be: Why would I limit myself to just one length?
I also play a 20.375" scale (U-Bass) and a 35" scale (5-string), and they all feel right to me, just different than each other, and I like the sound of each.
I've never even owned a 34" bass.
So my question would be: Why would I limit myself to just one length?
Jim Carr
Dr. Jim
- Jan 21, 2006
- 16,223
- 7,614
- 76
- Disclosures
- fEARful Kool-Aid dispensing liberal academic card-carrying union member Musicians Local 72-147
I play 32, 32.5, 34, 35, 41.5 and 42 inch scale basses. The last two are double basses, aka uprights.In the case of a 5-string... I'll give you that
IMHO, the sound a bass stringed instrument is very much affected by the interaction of the string length, string tension, string mass, and maximum string displacement (amplitude), especially when a magnetic pickup is involved.
I find E strings on my under 34" basses to feel quite floppy, and the 35" B strings really do feel and sound better to me than 34" B's.
Finally, I must admit I find your assertion that shorter scale is "easier," to be just an opinion. I don't find that to be true at all.
However, if you are happy with your instrument, I am glad.
They're kid's instruments. I played a short scale when i was 9. Now I play a man's instrument.
because my band sometimes tunes down to F0 and I'm not getting that to sound as good on a 30" scale bass as it does on my Dingwall.
OK, this is NOT serious - but I think he likes it
So, MakoMan...
Just for the record, does your other hobby involve smacking Yellow Jacket nests with a stick?
Just for the record, does your other hobby involve smacking Yellow Jacket nests with a stick?
Sadly, one factor is that it's what a lot of people have muscle memory for. Another thing is that you don't always want to use higher tension strings of a certain size just to get decent tension and tone. I'm sure many strides have been made, but I'd need to go try out some more shorties to see if any blow my hair back. Anything smaller than the Ibanez SR necks starts getting too cramped for me.
SirMjac28
Patiently Waiting For The Next British Invasion
Ask yourself this. How do baby grand pianos sound compared to full size grand pianos? How do mini guitars sound compared to full size guitars? The lower you go the longer the scale length needs or should be. Also I'm 6'5" tall 280lbs. I'd look like a bear riding a tricycle. [Invalid or Expired Link Removed]
