• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Will Smith just threw a $50m punch

Just sayin'...

FPDdvEjVEAMFUPR?format=jpg&name=medium.jpg


FPDd2NCUYAM48nH?format=png&name=small.png
 
Audience members attacking comedians, other performers, athletes, etc. is nothing new. The consequences are usually swift and direct. The only reason we didn't see that Sunday night was that it involved an A-list actor. A fitting outcome would have been Will Smith standing in the parking lot when his award was announced.

Academy Board of Governors member Whoopi Goldberg tried to explain on The View why the Oscar Management team decided against removing Smith after the assault. What she said needs elaboration, if I'm going to fully understand it...

 
Whoopi Goldberg and Joy Behar both appeared to be dumbfounded by Will Smiths action.
Similarly many other comedians are expressing outrage. Of course! They are comedians, clueless to the fact that not everyone appreciates their work.

Will Smith was actually very clear in his message, which seemed to be, "Joke about me all you want, but leave my wife out of it." He was the most clear thinking person at the whole event.

This event was not an attack on performers, such as musicians and actors. But it may signal a decline in the appeal of these kind of insulting comedians.
 
Last edited:
Whoopi Goldberg and Joy Behar both appeared to be dumbfounded by Will Smiths action.
Similarly many other comedians are expressing outrage. Of course! They are comedians, clueless to the fact that not everyone appreciates their work.

Will Smith was actually very clear in his message, which seemed to be, "Joke about me all you want, but leave my wife out of it." He was the most clear thinking person at the whole event.

This event was not an attack on performers, such as musicians and actors. But it may signal a decline in the appeal of these kind of insulting comedians.

That is NOT the way the winds are blowing.
 
Whoopi Goldberg and Joy Behar both appeared to be dumbfounded by Will Smiths action.
Similarly many other comedians are expressing outrage. Of course! They are comedians, clueless to the fact that not everyone appreciates their work.

Will Smith was actually very clear in his message, which seemed to be, "Joke about me all you want, but leave my wife out of it." He was the most clear thinking person at the whole event.

This event was not an attack on performers, such as musicians and actors. But it may signal a decline in the appeal of these kind of insulting comedians.
Most people do not want to condone assault, which is illegal, or equate it to someone making a joke while performing as a comedian and a KNOWN quantity, which is not illegal.

I don't think that acting rashly in a way that might well get you arrested is clear thinking. I had a long discussion earlier today with someone who was attempting to whine about how she was bullied as a child and therefore feels that giving the bully his due was justified. Well, I was bullied as a child too, and I understand that mean-spirited humor is weaponized, but these are two grown ADULTS, they are not children in a schoolyard. Adults should model more appropriate behavior.

Smith is lucky charges were not pressed. Had it been anyone else, anywhere else, he would have been detained by security and led away from the premises in handcuffs.
 
Last edited:
My wife made an interesting comment about this. Right now Smith is getting mixed reviews about this outburst, but what if it had been any female comic making the joke? Will Smith would be finished in Hollywood, period. What if Jada had slapped Chris Rock? She would have gotten a standing ovation. Double standards all over the place.

It seems to me nobody came out of that looking good, it's merely who came away from it looking the least bad. It was a string of wrongs not making a right. Rock's joke was lame to begin with then Will Smith said hold my beer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The two things on TV I live for, The Academy Awards and The View.


My favorite thing about this song is the Iggy and The Stooges style clap track.

//I truly can hardly stand watching TV anymore. I like Painting With John though.

///This is my way of expressing how much, in the whole scheme of things "The Slap" matters to me.
 
Last edited:
It seems to me nobody came out of that looking good, it's merely who came away from it looking the least bad. It was a string of wrongs not making a right. Rock's joke was lame to begin with then Will Smith said hold my beer.
This. Guy half slaps other guy. Dumb and a poor example. He's an actor, I don't follow his behavioral lead. He's not a thug (that's a loaded word isn't it?) he just did a stupid thing.

The sky isn't falling down because of what went on at the Oscars, it's falling down due to other much more impactfull stuff.
 
Last edited by a moderator: