• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

"You're terrible!"

I've been in situations where people told us things like "I liked the Blondie tune" (we did all original music), and have figured out a response that works well for that situation. Though your situation is different, I suggest next time, you try it out:

Her: "This is the wrong music for these people. Everyone hates this music."

You: Thanks!

She may get confused by this, but her showing up to an 80's party, expecting Chopin - she's already confused. Chances are, after your response, she will be taken aback, and pause to collect her thoughts. That's you cue to smile and quickly move away. No matter what her reaction is, it'll probably shorten the exchange, which is good for both you and her - you're not going to ever agree on anything, given her opening salvo, so don't try to engage her further. Be nice, say thanks, and move on.

Nah. I could have talked to her all night.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
For the record:

- She did not have dementia (though I'm not a doctor). She was not confused about what she heard or said. She hated the music. That's all. She got around fine on her own. Staff was not paying particular attentiun to her. After the episode she sat back down with two apparent friends and all were turned to face the band. They could have faced away - they were at long tables with their backs to the tables. All had sour pusses on their faces. Twenty minutes later she got up and went inside.

- There was no misunderstanding regarding the gig and the music requested. It was an 80s themed party. Centerpieces were large Rubiks Cubes. The staff and some residents were decked out in 80s style clothing.

She mentioned other music she likes besides Chopin, but I couldn't hear everything she said. Safe to assume it was other classical composers. I doubt she would enjoy any amplified band.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
For the record:

- She did not have dementia (though I'm not a doctor). She was not confused about what she heard or said. She hated the music.

One of the first things to go with dementia is your "filter" - that whole social grace thing where you don't say stuff that you're thinking (because you want to be nice) sometimes goes out the window. With my Mom, that was certainly true at times.

So yeah, she really hated your music, but a decade younger, she probably wouldn't have said it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Williethump
One of the first things to go with dementia is your "filter" - that whole social grace thing where you don't say stuff that you're thinking (because you want to be nice) sometimes goes out the window. With my Mom, that was certainly true at times.

So yeah, she really hated your music, but a decade younger, she probably wouldn't have said it.
Agreed, that does happen. But then many old people (not me and I'm 72) feel pretty much free to say whatever they think even absent dementia. Old and set in their ways and ofttimes loudmouthed curmudgeons who voice whatever thought passes through their brains. Which, just like their bodies, don't work so well any longer. Stay flexible in mind and body, you youts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
Agreed, that does happen. But then many old people (not me and I'm 72) feel pretty much free to say whatever they think even absent dementia. Old and set in their ways and ofttimes loudmouthed curmudgeons who voice whatever thought passes through their brains. Which, just like their bodies, don't work so well any longer. Stay flexible in mind and body, you youts.
We've been here a long time, we've seen things.

:)
 
For a car show, you want greaser rock and not 80's style band stuff. Each has their place, but this appears to have been a mismatch. By greaser rock I mean Steppenwolf, Black Sabbath, Cream, Hendrix, Mountain, CCR, or any other similar early era blues/rock. You could also get away with late 50's / early 60's nostalgia stuff too if the cars are ancient enough.
 
Into... "CLUTCHING YOUR PILLOW TIYYY-TUH!"
I saw Metallica in the 90’s, I think it was the old Arena in Seattle. It would have been the Sandman tour I think. The crowd threw the folding chairs into a giant pile in the middle of the floor, and were climbing them. I made my way down to the floor (from the high up back seats). I tried to make my way to the front, past this giant dude. He grabbed my t-shirt to prevent me going by him, and tore it off instead. He shrugged, and I watched the rest of that chaotic show up front.
 
Band: 80s New Wave/Pop band
Gig: 80s party & mini car show
Location: Assisted living facility (parking lot)

You might be able to tell where this is going.

About halfway through our single 90 minute set a literal little old lady (5'0", 85 years old) walks up onto the stage saying something to me that I can't hear because it was mid song. Maybe she was coming to complain about the lack of hair metal, so I leaned over to give her my ear.

Her: "This is the wrong music for these people. Everyone hates this music."

Me (to myself): It's a Billy Idol song. I hate it too.

Me (to her): "It's an 80s party. This is what they hired us to play."

Her: "It sucks!"

Me: "Again, this is what they hired us to play."

Her: "It's sh*t! And you're terrible! I don't listen to this garbage. I listen to Chopin."

Me: "I don't have an orchestra with me. We can't play that tonight."

This wasn't enough of an answer for her. She now had to tell the drummer how much we suck, mid song. He couldn't hear a word she was saying.

At this point a staff member noticed her and retrieved her from the stage.

She had a point. They shouldn't have an 80s party at an assisted living facility until it's my time to live there. They should have had a band playing 50s-70s music. But her complaint should be directed at management, not us.

She was exceptionally rude, but it was entertaining and I get a good story to tell.

Side note: The mini car show included a 60s Batmobile, the Green Arrow's car (does that have a name?), the General Lee and sheriff car, and a DeLorean with all the Back to the Future equipment. (None from the actual shows/movies).

Reminds me of a wedding I played at about 20 odd years ago (we were 4 piece rock covers band)
about 3 songs into the first set an elderly lady with a zimmer frame comes up to lead guitarist and said "I don't like this Jazzy music you're playing".
LG says "we're not a jazz band"
So we continue playing and the lady comes up again and says "You're playing too much Jazzy music - I don't like this Jazzy music"!
LG again tells the lady we're not a jazz band and we're not playing 'jazzy' music
This happened about 3 more times in the first set.... then we had a break.
Bride asked about a song and LG said "Look I don't know who the lady over there in the zimmer frame is, but if she tells us once more to stop playing Jazzy music I'll whack her with my guitar"!

Bride looks over then says "Oh that's my Grandma - don't worry about her she's tone deaf"!
We didn't see the old lady again and even had a request for Rage Against The Machine....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sam Evans
Reminds me of a wedding I played at about 20 odd years ago (we were 4 piece rock covers band)
about 3 songs into the first set an elderly lady with a zimmer frame comes up to lead guitarist and said "I don't like this Jazzy music you're playing".
LG says "we're not a jazz band"
So we continue playing and the lady comes up again and says "You're playing too much Jazzy music - I don't like this Jazzy music"!
LG again tells the lady we're not a jazz band and we're not playing 'jazzy' music
This happened about 3 more times in the first set.... then we had a break.
Bride asked about a song and LG said "Look I don't know who the lady over there in the zimmer frame is, but if she tells us once more to stop playing Jazzy music I'll whack her with my guitar"!

Bride looks over then says "Oh that's my Grandma - don't worry about her she's tone deaf"!
We didn't see the old lady again and even had a request for Rage Against The Machine....

If you're old enough, all that new-fangled music is JAZZ, man ...
 
I have a theory that it’s socially unacceptable to punch old people in the face so they can just be rude a-holes because there’s no punishment. Also some older folks are just cranky old miserable people (trust me I’m turning into one) and nothing makes them happy.

Unfortunately she was the turd in the lunch bowl that day. Part of dealing with the public. Laugh it off and learn to play another day.
 
Most of the time people are very gracious when I play out. They cone up to us and say very nice things. But every once in a while, somebody insults you, whether directly or indirectly. It’s just part of putting yourself and your art out there.

I remember one gig where we took a break, and a drunk guy came up to us and said, “I should be your guitar player. I’m better than him!” While pointing at our GP. The GP, a lifelong friend, said “get your own band, a**hole!” We laughed and the guy slunk away, back to the rock he crawled out from.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BassGuyFL