@scott sinner
Honest impression of the boss SY200?
I want to incorporate synth sounds in my band but I want to keep things simple.
(Read I don’t want to carry around a hardware synth, or a soft synth iPad combo. I already run 2 amps. )
Thank you for any opinions/pros cons
Etc
Not really looking at the C4, I don’t want to connect to a computer on a gig to EQ a sound that needs tweaking.
Pros:
I don't know if you've ever used a audio to synth pedal that uses FFT rather than pitch to midi, but, for me that is a big pro. Skip this if this is old news to you. Basically you have some pedals that try to detect the pitch and then use that as midi to trigger an oscillator(s). There are some advantages to that for some people in that it will give you a purer synth tone, unaffected by the timbre of your instrument. The disadvantages include that that tracking is actually quite hard for an instrument to do. You get errors and artifacts. Though sometimes those can be fun too.
The sy series, and some EHXs are essentially grafting the sound on to the audio input. That is why they can be polyphonic. That also means that your timbre comes through readily. I consider that the big advantage of this type. I can play keys. If I dont want the nuance of my intimate finger controlled input to do stuff, Ill play keys.
Very easy to use.
Has a good variety of classic synth sounds. Enough controls to get them usable.
MIDI controlled is a huge plus for me. My whole pedalboard changes presets together.
The giant LCD is a gift to my aging eyes.
Cons
I thought the stock presets were meh, but I always think that.
If you don't already have a multieffect pedal, I kinda think that is a must with it for a couple reasons.
Mainly, there are two ways I think the sound quality is lacking. Some of the oscillators are just, I guess, too clean. Im no foe of digital oscillators. I have loved some digital Eurorack units, all my soft synths. But some of these dont seem much modelled on anything but math.
A little dirt though, or a chewy compressor, and youre golden.
Likewise, I don't love the filtering. Again, I use the filters on a multieffect or on a Moog MF Drive and Im happy to use it even in the most studio recording context.
If I were only concerned about using it live, I wouldnt really care. It isnt bad, just I am pretty picky about my synth sounds probably.