I think it's time for me to finally get a hardware polysynth snd have been thinking far too much about it. So apologies for the length of this post. I'd appreciate insight from anyone and everyone.
I have the cash saved up. I am going to pick up a Micromonsta for my band rig when they're available again in January, but I want something more 1-knob-per-function-y for home use now that my away from the computer setup is happening. I've been doing my reading and listening and would love to hear if anyone has any thoughts here. Unfortunately, there are zero stores with a return policy for two of my three options (I can get the Prophet mail order from Long and McQuade, which does allow returns).
Here's what I want:
a) a desktop module with patch memory
b) that at least theoretically could do MPE at some point
c) that is fun to program
d) has a good basic sound to start with
e) that can sound nasty and dirty--not necessarily elephantine like a mono synth but distorted. I sometimes want clean but I am very much in a "dirty" phase at the moment. I do have monos for elephantine sounds so I'm not looking for huge bass, just not super-clean.
Right now my candidates are the Iridium, Prophet 6, and Super 6. Everyone says Hydrasynth is fun to program but not as awesome sounding as the other 3. I have listened to tons of demos but don't totally believe them. Normally this could be resolved with 10 minutes at a synth store, but places like Moog Audio won't even let you touch the stock right now.
The Prophet 6 is very WYSIWYG. It has a good basic sound in the neighbourhood of what I'm thinking of and is flexible within "standard analog synth" territory. MPE works. I worry that it's too simple in a way. MPE and modulation options are limited. But I can always sequence parameters from my Vector or Octatrack because of its excellent MIDI implementation, and you can program the Linnstrument to send any message you want on the Y axis.
The Super Six: The desktop form factor and interface looks perfect for me. More capable than the Prophet--everything on the front panel can be modulated from the front panel (with a couple exceptions). But seems to have a cleaner sound. No MPE yet but it's promised and the developer seems to deliver on promises, though not immediately. I can wait. Demos are all pretty clean and tinkle, though the new firmware update is said to have better FM (waiting to hear it demoed). I think I would need the Erica Acidbox or OTO Boum or something after it to get the tones I'm seeking. The stereo spread thing through a distortion or ring mod or frequency shifter could be pretty nuts.
The Iridium: Reports (including here) are that the MPE is working well in the 3.0 beta. Everyone on this thread that has one seems to love it. I love the theoretical range of engines on it -- combining sample and FM or virtual analog and physical modelling in one patch could be sick. I would instantly load up the Fairlight sample set and go nuts.
—how much do you have to use the touchscreen? I’m not a jam-and-tweak the touchscreen kind of guy. I don’t mind it for deeper settings and naming patches, etc., but would want to be able to use knobs when jamming.
—relatedly, would you say it is fun to program? I’d mostly build my own patches and love the idea of mixing samples and synthesis. But for instance, Loopop seemed to grumble a bit about the mod matrix in his review.
—can you get it to sound dirty or nasty? I know audio rate modulation on some oscillators is limited. Seems like there are lots of options on the synth for dirt elsewhere, but I haven’t heard much of this demos. Lot of huge pads and ambient stuff but that’s not what I’m after.
EDIT: I could also join the Lyra club here, but I kind of want a more traditional poly at least to start.