• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

basses on you tube...really? Slap rant...

Don't you know that the only way to gauge a good bass player is by how well he slaps? :smug:

If you can't slap a bass like it's 1978, then your hopeless. ;)

Lol!!! Yeah I'm pretty hopeless..Seriously, if you want to work, and I have been since since 1968, you'd better be able to play what the music calls for, slap included in the old tool box. As for the OP, slap is just another art form, and either you apreciate or not.

Personally, I'd rather hear paradiddles performed on percussion instruments as opposed to the bass. Much like you can play bass parts on a piccolo, it loses something in the translation. JMO
 
  • Like
Reactions: murphy
I don't slap often, and when I do it's not pretty. I sometimes watch reviews on YouTube and they usually contain slapping. I drive an automobile and occasionally need a new one. At that time, I do diligent research on the models of interest. If the car being shown is a Dodge Challenger Hellcat Redeye, the expectation is that of speed, acceleration and other high fuel consumption feats. If the model in question is a Toyota Prius, the criteria to judge it on would be a little different. The same can be said for gear demos. The most useful kind of bass demo would contain examples of each pickup combination with the tone knobs in various positions performing slap, fingerstyle and picking techniques in a few different musical settings. This would give the widest audience of bassists the information needed. For many of us, longer notes that showcase their attack, bloom and decay would be helpful. That seems to be one area of demos that are routinely absent. Granted, for mere entertainment, twelve or fifteen seconds of A 440 isn't exactly thrilling. Informative, but boring. Chances are poor for gathering large numbers of subscribers by playing whole notes.
 
Slapping was a novelty used by the founders of funk and later found its way into basically every style. Back in the 80s I found it intriguing but gradually that minor appreciation for the style turned into disdain. The moment I hear a YT reviewer slapping something longer than 1 bar, I turn it off. I can barely tolerate a cat like Ed Friedland's slap portion of his reviews because as a pro, he has to showcase all sonic options, regretfully. My 2 cent rant. Apologies.
 
I like reviews where they play different styles to give you an idea of the sound, finger plucking, pick, and yes....slapping.
I happen to enjoy playing old school funk, so it certainly helps to hear how the bass plays when being slapped in my case. However, I also want to hear how it sounds being played with da fingers. NO PICKS...that's for guitars and strumming chords. Who the hell does that? lol....joking of course. All styles, different flavors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jamro217
It all depends on the channels you watch. And it's always good to hear some pick, fingerpick, slap, and palm mute. Also, some channels have good audio and video content and some have crappy audio and low quality video. Check out the audio and video quality of this channel, and best with 4K.
 
Passe'?? Novelty?? Sorry but...........NO! It's a legitimate technique just like any other. Again guys, there is other music out there beside rock, metal and country! If slap ain't for you...cool. But please stop with the negative rhetoric! So NOT cool!

Larry Graham would have something to say about the technique he created being called a novelty! SMDH!
 
images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRLlpihgIAZfHryBaMyJcmiwRd9x7eVVJlz0i-Ysa-WfGrYrUOB1g.jpg


images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQmb_5PpE0WX9iiE9NxqhshCdoaumf20-RXHRUY1I8xp58LazYD.jpg


e8ebceaf400d5335b5a3a318f8d5dd60--skrillex-music-quotes.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: saabfender
the thing about slapping is that whenever I meet anyone that knows nothing about bass playing or music in general really and see that i play, they always ask me to slappa the bass.

that's the target audience of many of these videos.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HolmeBass