Sorry... it's a long story.Where the heck have you been Tom, you're the life blood of this clubJim
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Sorry... it's a long story.Where the heck have you been Tom, you're the life blood of this clubJim
Add me to the list....
![]()
![]()
![]()
Sorry for losing track of this. I've assigned you a number (see above). Welcome aboard.
Hmm, I would think that if you're having problems with your left hand and arm you might want to stay away from 6 string basses because of the extra stretch of the left hand.Might even consider a 4 string F with a narrower fretboard. I'm just thinking fretting the B string on a 6 string, especially F 6ers with the wide fretboard, might be putting some stress on your hand and arm. If I was having that problem I would only play my old Jazz for awhile and see if my condition improves. Do you own any 4 stringers with relatively narrow necks? JimAs some may know, health problems with my left hand and arm have put me on the path to bass retirement -- I've just been walking it as slowly as I can.Along the way, I have been "thinning the herd," saying reluctant goodbyes to basses along the way.
As I ponder exactly what basses I want if I were to own only 2 or 3, I realize that the maple boarded BN5 I own, and the ebony boarded BN6 I have, should probably become just one bass: a BN6 with a maple board.
Am I correct in thinking that a BN6 with a maple finger board sounds very much like a BN5 with a maple board?
I know the added mass at the heal of the neck of a BN6 alters the bass's tone, and depending on the year, the BN6's pickup placement isn't exactly the same placement as a BN5's.
Any thoughts? Anyone have a maple boarded BN6 that can me help out?
By the way, if anybody is interested in the old Studio Series Fbass, George is making a run of 6 of them. A really beautiful one is on the website right now. JimHmm, I would think that if you're having problems with your left hand and arm you might want to stay away from 6 string basses because of the extra stretch of the left hand.Might even consider a 4 string F with a narrower fretboard. I'm just thinking fretting the B string on a 6 string, especially F 6ers with the wide fretboard, might be putting some stress on your hand and arm. If I was having that problem I would only play my old Jazz for awhile and see if my condition improves. Do you own any 4 stringers with relatively narrow necks? Jim
As some may know, health problems with my left hand and arm have put me on the path to bass retirement -- I've just been walking it as slowly as I can.Along the way, I have been "thinning the herd," saying reluctant goodbyes to basses along the way.
As I ponder exactly what basses I want if I were to own only 2 or 3, I realize that the maple boarded BN5 I own, and the ebony boarded BN6 I have, should probably become just one bass: a BN6 with a maple board.
Am I correct in thinking that a BN6 with a maple finger board sounds very much like a BN5 with a maple board?
I know the added mass at the heal of the neck of a BN6 alters the bass's tone, and depending on the year, the BN6's pickup placement isn't exactly the same placement as a BN5's.
Any thoughts? Anyone have a maple boarded BN6 that can me help out?
Hmm, I would think that if you're having problems with your left hand and arm you might want to stay away from 6 string basses because of the extra stretch of the left hand.Might even consider a 4 string F with a narrower fretboard. I'm just thinking fretting the B string on a 6 string, especially F 6ers with the wide fretboard, might be putting some stress on your hand and arm. If I was having that problem I would only play my old Jazz for awhile and see if my condition improves. Do you own any 4 stringers with relatively narrow necks? Jim
I've had an ash/maple bn5 and bn6. They were both great basses but I liked the bn6 better tonally. I've played other ash/maple bn5's that were slammin though, so it may be more about the resonance of the individual woods than the string count.
Tom,
It sounds like you have a connection with these instruments. Even though they are built by the same builder, each instrument is its own thing. If you develop a connection with one, it doesn't matter what you get, because it won't be that specific instrument that you have bonded with. Just my 2 cents.
I kinda know what you mean with FBasses.I've definitely bonded with these basses, which is why I couldn't just sell them when I realized my playing days were numbered.
As some may know, health problems with my left hand and arm have put me on the path to bass retirement -- I've just been walking it as slowly as I can.Along the way, I have been "thinning the herd," saying reluctant goodbyes to basses along the way.
Any thoughts? Anyone have a maple boarded BN6 that can me help out?
BTW, I do tap, but not that often, and NOTHING like what Trey Gunn is doing.Hi Tom, I am very sorry to hear about this, I thought something was cooking as you've not been around much. Not to be innocently hopeful or to throw at you advice you have not asked for, but my Warr Guitar teacher, the great Trey Gunn plays his Warr (which is a tapping instrument) sitting down, and he has spent quite a lot of time working this technique. On that position, whereas your left hand would "fret" the notes as a keyboard, it would be in way less tension than hanging as when you play the bass.
I understand this may be totally out of the question, but I once thought I would never have my right hand tap using all my fingers and after some work ... it is my "favourite" fretting hand believe it or not, way faster than my fret hand that has been doing this forever.
If at least you are intrigued, I would give Trey a call and ask for a 1h coaching session, this could (I definitively wish it does) give you an alternative to selling your beauties. Just a friendly thought, I hope it helps.
Best regards,
Thanks, Gustavo. I'll give it some thought.
I LOVE Wes's BN5 tone on this clip, but when I watch Wes really pushing against the limitations of the bass for high notes in this solo, it makes me want to have a BN6 as one of my last basses, and not necessarily a BN5.
It's funny, I'm completely the opposite. I've never liked 24 fret 34" scale basses. Had several Carvins years ago and sent them all back during the try out period because first position seemed too much of a stretch, could feel the bass shift on my shoulder strap slightly whenever I was at the first couple of frets and became OCD over it. Same thing with more boutique type basses that I've tried in stores. One of the things I like about the BN series is how the whole neck is shifted towards the right side of your body slightly, if you're are right handed, which brings first position in a little closer. I know some players on TB who didn't like that, couldn't get used to how it hung on a strap and sold theirs. For me it's a advantage, I don't even notice the 34.5 scale because of it. I wear my bass fairly high though, so players who sling it lower probably won't notice the difference. My 10 lbs. BN was such a relief from my 12lbs. SR5, which I still have, that it never seemed heavy to me. If I start to think it's heavy I just strap on the Stingray for an hour or so and the F magically becomes light again ! JimI kinda know what you mean with FBasses.
I haven't even had my FBass a year, but I had really been struggling with keeping my BN5 fretless a couple of months back as it is completely wrong for me. It isn't 34" scale, isn't under 9.5lbs and doesn't have 24 frets. All of my main basses are light and have 24 frets and are 34" scale.
In any case, I really want to hate and not be able to play my 22 fret, 34.5" 10lb+ monster of a FBass so I can decide it isn't right for me and ultimately sell it for something that fits my preferred spec.... Nope. I can't do it. My fretless BN5 just sounds and plays so damned good. My back and technique will have to get used to this bass, I guess.![]()
I have to agree about the first position being a bit closer than normal now that I look at the bass. That is definately why the 34.5" of the FBass is workable for me then.It's funny, I'm completely the opposite. I've never liked 24 fret 34" scale basses. Had several Carvins years ago and sent them all back during the try out period because first position seemed too much of a stretch, could feel the bass shift on my shoulder strap slightly whenever I was at the first couple of frets and became OCD over it. Same thing with more boutique type basses that I've tried in stores. One of the things I like about the BN series is how the whole neck is shifted towards the right side of your body slightly, if you're are right handed, which brings first position in a little closer. I know some players on TB who didn't like that, couldn't get used to how it hung on a strap and sold theirs. For me it's a advantage, I don't even notice the 34.5 scale because of it. I wear my bass fairly high though, so players who sling it lower probably won't notice the difference. My 10 lbs. BN was such a relief from my 12lbs. SR5, which I still have, that it never seemed heavy to me. If I start to think it's heavy I just strap on the Stingray for an hour or so and the F magically becomes light again ! Jim