Mr. Newsted is in the green Sadowsky club as well!
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Sadowsky pickup question: can anyone briefly describe the tonal difference(s) between the Sad soapbar and p-bass pickups, in both active and passive modes?

Sadowsky has used different P-bass pickups over the years. My 2005 P5 has a Duncan... I think? My 2010 P5 came with a Nordstrand NP5. I assume you're curious about whichever is currently being used, but I don't know what that is -- or what they are, if there are options.
I have not heard the Sadowsky soapbar so I couldn't answer your question regardless... just here to point out the complication.![]()
Don't know who's P pickup is in it though the cover says Sadowsky.
Will testify to matching photo...you guys perfectly captured the Caribbean Sea with mine.Yes, we've done a similar silverburst finish... unfortunately, our sold gallery is down right now, but when it's back up, there should be an example.
And if you give us a sample photo, we can always match it.
The pickup in my 2010 P5 is branded Sadowsky. The Nordstrand giveaway is the offset/diagonal polepieces. I have no idea how to tell the origin when the polepieces are not offset -- maybe the shop would know?
I believe (correct me if I am wrong) the non-offset p bass pickups are made by Seymour Duncan to Roger's specs.
All of Roger's PUs are made to his spec.
Correct, the offset p bass polepieces indicate Norstrand.
I don't see Sadowsky single coil pickups in their online store anymore...? Or any pickups at all...
Can someone link me?
I don't see Sadowsky single coil pickups in their online store anymore...? Or any pickups at all...
Can someone link me?

Speaking of pickups... just swapped out the stock Sadowskys in my Modern for Nordy Big Splits. And it was a chance to use a Tech Box I just snagged on eBay. #almostpro
These will go a little better with the stuff I normally play. I love the Sadowsky pickups too... so clear and modern. But the bass will get more use now along with my PJ5.
And, as a weird side benefit, it's like 5 oz lighter now... 8lb 7oz down to under 8lb 2oz.
View attachment 3129655 View attachment 3129656 View attachment 3129657 View attachment 3129658
Again THANK YOU Roger for the Hospitality and for dropping some serious science on me today.
That bass is beautiful, even without pickupsSpeaking of pickups... just swapped out the stock Sadowskys in my Modern for Nordy Big Splits. And it was a chance to use a Tech Box I just snagged on eBay. #almostpro
These will go a little better with the stuff I normally play. I love the Sadowsky pickups too... so clear and modern. But the bass will get more use now along with my PJ5.
And, as a weird side benefit, it's like 5 oz lighter now... 8lb 7oz down to under 8lb 2oz.
View attachment 3129655 View attachment 3129656 View attachment 3129657 View attachment 3129658
Gorgeous! I often wonder how my Metro Modern compares to the NYC version.My NYC 5-24 satin deluxe in caramel burst came in a few days ago. I haven’t been able to put it down since. It is a big upgrade over my metro MV5. It blew me away with superior playability, quality, tone, and weight. Thank you Roger for building such a phenomenal instrument!View attachment 3129700