• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

could you please sell me on Jaco?

Well, 4001, we all can burp after a good beer and ... then? Jazz sucks? Ahahah ... and Bon Jovi is good music ? Ahahah ... OMG ... let’s say that since not all of us can be Weather Report, some of them decide to be Bon Jovi ...
Which Jazz?

There are plenty of Jazz ballads that can fill the floor when played as the last song of the night.

There are more than a few Rock songs with Jazz solos - start with The Doors & Steeley Dan.


I was just kidding. I'm a big jazz head. "A Remark You Made" is a fine song for the last one of the night....

You couldn't get me to play Bon Jovi tunes for anything....
 
No its not.....

its a Pee Wee Ellis cover....

and Jaco aknowledges that plenty of times, as well as his other (EDIT) borrowed licks.

"....I'm just an imitator, man....."
Yes, but Pee Wee Ellis was the Sax player in James Brown's band and wrote the tune then. I do believe it was first recorded by James Brown.
 
Jaco was one of kind for these reasons:
1) he was the pioneer of the fretless bass on which he created a whole new very expressive and melodic style.
2) he was an incredible player, his solo albums, his work with Weather Report, Joni Mitchell, etc.
3) and most importantly for me he was an amazing composer. His album word of mouth showed me that here’s this phenomenal bass player who can also write gorgeous tunes for jazz orchestra.
It’s rare that a musician covers these 3 areas.
 
Since the original post asked for help in appreciating Jaco, I'll offer the track which first grabbed me: Joni Mitchell's "Refuge of the Roads." This is early Jaco, and he's very restrained and lyrical. His imagination and creativity are WAY beyond what anyone else was doing at the time.
I knew him briefly, in 1977-78, and he told me the story of how he played on this album ("Hejira"). He was still mostly unknown at the time, and someone recommended him to Mitchell. His "audition" was this: He went into the studio after everyone else except the engineer had gone, and added bass parts to the basic tracks. (He listened once, then did his thing.) The next day, Joni came in, listened, and was blown away.
Listen in particular to what he does on the word "thunderhead"-- again, no other bassist was doing anything like this. It had an huge effect on me.

 
I like Jaco. I don't like how it always seems like I have to be told how much to like Jaco, and that it always seems I don't like him enough. I feel like Jaco fans get upset just reading this.

He was great, game changer. But for me, so was John Paul Jones, Jack Bruce, Lemmy, Steve Harris, and god how many others?? He can groove. So could Bootsy and Jamerson. He was musical. So was Bruce and Jones. He had a way of playing jazz that was unique, so was Mingus. I don't know, I think he's great but somehow I get the feeling from players that love him that I don't think he was great enough, and that because of that I'm missing something and don't truly appreciate or understand the instrument, and that's annoying to be honest.

It's like Goldilocks, man; as far as I'm concerned you have it just right :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: madmarvin
Some dudes posted a video of the genius of Cliff Williams (bass player from AC/DC) because he was playing the 3rd of a chord instead of the root while the guitar players were playing 5th chords... it must have been viral as I saw it in theee different places, including Talkbass. SMDH...

I liked that about Cliff before YouTube existed. Not that I think he was a genius, but I recognize that he did more for simple songs than most bassists by the way he decided the chords. Matter of fact, when I first started looking for bands, I used to advertise that I was influenced by everyone from Cliff Williams (who plays 180 steady 8ths in a row in Thunderstruck with no deviation) to Adrian Davison (a bass shredder that advertised that he could cram 31 notes into a single second - I also enjoyed that his ad triggered Anthony Jackson).
 
It depends on the kind of music you enjoy yourself with ... if you like death metal then I may say that Jaco is not the bass player for you most likely ...

Absolutely wrong. The best bassists in death metal, from Steve DiGiorgio to Sean Malone to Forest LaPointe, are often players with a clear Jaco influence. Matter of fact, the fretless bass is rarely being championed these days in American music except in jazz and technical death metal!
 
Guys.. it's like saying that Schwarzenegger was not the king of the body builders of its time because irrationally we never liked him .. the truth is that Jaco was a super groover ... his mastery of the 16th notes style with ghost notes, upbeat notes etc was and is phenomenal ... secondly he was a musician far beyond the limits of his primary instrument .. he took the language of be-bop jazz and played it on the electric bass wherever possible... somebody mentioned Stanley Clarke ... Stanley was an amazing funky man with an excellent technique but his musical language was and is substantially limited harmonically wise (pentatonic man we may call him .. Good and well played pentatonic scales but always the same register more or less) ... unfortunately the poor Jaco became mad and probably he also didn't do much to save himself .. in his late recordings you can find the same killer funky refrain of Come on Come over in pieces of tunes which were supposed to be much more jazz oriented, that is not in the right place frankly . . He was doing what he could to remain alive in musical industry terms ... he was without doubts a master musician what, for instance, I don't consider Marcus Miller to be, although I like him a lot ... don't know if these words may contribute towards getting sold about Jaco's works but you may try to listen to what I co wider one of his landmark tunes .. Barbary Coast ... however music is a question of mindset .
. Certain chords of our mind can or cannot be activated by certain external stimuli.. there's nothing to do in this regard. . We're not all the same!

I love your Schwarzenegger reference - dead on analogy! I don't downplay Stanley though. Both greats had their highs and lows, but Stanley at his best was always more exciting to me than Jaco. Something to do with the forward motion of his groove. And Stanley was top tier on both upright and electric which is amazing for a doubler, even in 2012 I saw him play an absolutely amazing solo piece on an instrument that destroys hands, and he's no young rooster!