I had posted earlier about this, wanted to get some more feedback.
I have a Super P5 which I'm very happy with. It has great clarity, even response, and punch. It's currently my #1 player.
However, compared to my Fender P5, it is much more round and mellow sounding. They are both alder/morado instruments, both with pretty new Chromes. The Fender is abrasively bright sounding when soloed with the tone all the way up, which I think is the traditional P sound, and it works well in a rock mix. In contrast, the Super P sounds perfect soloed, but in a thick mix it doesn't have much "bite" to it. I can hear every note (better than the Fender), but digging in doesn't give me that "clank" or "snap" that I get with the Fender. It sounds great, but a bit more relaxed and hi-fi than the Fender. Is this the sound of Super P's? Or are there different windings or variations on the Dingwall P pickup?
I don't want to lose the nice midrange and lows of the SP5, but it would be nice to get some of that clankiness which sounds bad soloed but good in the mix.
I know I can eq or change strings, but I'm looking to kind of change the "baseline" sound of the instrument a bit, tilt it away from polite, and toward aggressive (I like the flats, so I don't want to go roundwound if I can help it). Does anybody hear what I'm talking about? Is there a way to get that lo-fi aggression out of the SP5 without losing what makes it sound so great?