Like most disagreements, both great and small, there are multiple interpretations of the results to be drawn. Besides your interpretation, others would say the non-modelers won and kicked the modeling discussions out of the main thread
! 
Personally, I feel strongly both ways.
But there is so much overlap between the modeling and non-modeling Rumbles that, I think, it's still appropriate to gather those commonalities here, along with the V1 & V2 Rumbles, and even the original all-tube
Custom Shop Rumble, which shares only the name
!!!
.