Almost all drummers I work with have such a groove it's near impossible to not play in it, yet other band members do so...
...I hate clicks simply because they take away the natural ebb and floe of real music. If I wanted to hear that stuff, I'd put down the bass, play it on a keyboard with real time quantize set to stun.
Over the decades I've played with both, live and studio...always prefer without.
I went to a festival in a city park on the weekend.
Perfect illustration of the difference between quantized/highly scripted vs organic musicianship:
- Five Alarm Funk is performance art. Horns, two guitars, bass, drums, Congas and timbales/cowbell. Crazy costumes and props, lots of synchronized jumping and dancing, simple repetitive lyrics, as much about the party as the music. The energy level was absolutely relentless.
- An Argentinian band was on later that evening, playing tango/electronica. At first, I thought FOH was playing recorded music between sets. Everyone looked very intense and focused on their playing, but the end result lacked impact. They were supported by additional tracks and sequences controlled from side stage. There were some small attempts at communicating the mood via body language, but they seemed weak and forced.
Five Alarm Funk was on a mobile stage, off in a corner, but the audience was overflowing in all directions, and going nuts. They pretty much owned the park. The other group was dead-centre in the big bandshell, yet their audience was smaller, and totally passive.
To be sure, the funk band was louder and had more visual appeal. But a big part of their schtick was the fact that they were abolutely and unashamedly live and in the moment. No click, no sequences, and lots of interaction with the audience.
Their groove was tight as can be, but the tempos breathed naturally with the dynamics of the set. The drummer/lead vocalist was playing hard but simple, and would push the tempo as needed on the big builds.
Despite having an aggressive acoustic drummer, the Tango dudes couldn't follow audience reaction because they were tied to their technology. Musically sound, but dry and unapproachable compared to the bunch of sweaty louts on the other side of the park...
No wonder us old farts get so grumpy.