John Sprague said:So would a group that adopts a way of life that is not self-sustaining, which employs vast agricultural and fossil fuel resources to have its "special" food and clothing trucked all over the country, be considered a parasite? Me thinks they may well be.
Since when were vegans anti-technology? And the vast resources you mention--we haul clothes and food all over the country no matter whether they're "special" or not, and the amount of water and agricultural resources required to produce X amount of calories and protein via a cow, pig, or chicken is orders of magnitude greater than that required to produce the same amount of nutritional value through grains and vegetables.
No, I'm not a vegan or even a vegetarian, and I know that eating meat isn't unnatural. But stuffing animals full of hormones and antibiotics, growing them in such large numbers that their presence (feces, food requirements) causes serious environmental problems, and clear-cutting rain-forests just so a bunch of fat Americans can have meat three times a day (and therefore die of heart disease and colon cancer) just seems kind of pointless, and it's as far from the "natural" balance our ancestors knew with nature as limiting one's food intake entirely to plants. Internal combustion isn't evil, but getting in your gas-guzzling SUV to drive three blocks to the grocery store is just a waste of energy--and trying to drill for oil in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge when the amount of oil available there could be saved just through the US government actually implementing the fuel-efficiency standards it set for its own fleet of vehicles (as a random example) is, yes, unreasonable.
The point is, we're smart monkeys; we know not to crap in the river upstream from where we draw our water, or at least we used to, and we're capable of being responsible for our actions and not behaving suicidally. And the thought that the actions of one individual are insignificant is wrong--to get back on the topic, I'm sure that the guy who makes HIMA basses considers every sale to be important, and losing one potential sale affects him. Double basses aren't tennis shoes, after all, and the community of bassists is fairly close-knit. If one finds it distasteful to support the Chinese rape of Tibetan resources (if indeed this is what HIMA represents, which is still unclear to me...), just don't buy the basses. You don't have to take on the entire Chinese economy or feel unable to act because you come from a country with a wretched imperialist history of its own; your "dollar vote" still counts.
