How is the new P/J in comparison to the 2013 Pawn Shop. I have to say, even though I really want a MIA, this little guy as really peaked my interest. Even more so since the 2013 model didn't stick around too long. I really enjoyed this through a Rumble at GC the other day.
I own a PS Mustang and I love it. There are a couple of differences from the PJ I played at GC last week:
1) I feel like the fit and finish on my PS is a bit nicer. Maybe I'm just trying to justify the additional $250 I paid for it, but the PS is a bit heavier and a bit classier looking, especially with the sunburst finish, pearloid pickguard and thumbrest. The PJ satin neck was definitely very nice, but I still prefer the look of the original Mustang bridge, and the PS is string-through-body. I don't necessarily care about the through-body thing, but you may. Also the fret ends on my PS are cleaner - I'd say the PS feels more like an MIA bass than the PJ.
2) The PS is definitely a one trick pony. It's GREAT trick, but it only does one thing. The tone knob is basically useless. The PJ has many more tonal options.
I really dig my PS Mustang and while I like the PJ, I'm not going to sell mine to get one. If I didn't have the PS I'd definitely be interested.
To be honest, I didn't get to side-by-side compare them, and the PJ I played through a MarkBass combo I'm not familiar with so I can't comment on the general tone comparison. The PS humbucker is LOUD, so I don't know how that would compare. The PJ I tried also had a noticeable volume drop between the P and J pickup, but I'm sure that could be fixed with a setup. I got my PS from
Sweetwater and the setup was great - I haven't touched anything in a couple years since I got it.
Let me know if you have any other questions about the PS Mustang. Honestly, I'm surprised they weren't more popular - definitely a unique beast.