@steve_rolfeca: Man, I wish I had anybody like you to work on my instruments around here! Thank you for the detailed and thoughtful response. I know just enough about setting up instruments to know I should bring mine to somebody who knows better, but I have found truly great techs lacking in my area. I will probably bring a printout of this with me when I bring the instrument in.
So it wasn't just me, haha/groan.
Just the screw ... so far ...
I don't mean to overstate the imbalance between strings as currently set up; a lighter attack on the D and G mostly evens things out. I doubt a defect, but also hadn't considered it. Noted.
I had planned on having the new pickguard (black) and bridge (Hipshot Kickass) and electronics (M&V, not-cheap guts) all installed at once, but with the delay on the M&V, this convinces me to hold off on the electronics and see what I get with the new bridge and adjustments to the stock pickup (assuming somebody can get that totally stripped screw out, haha/groan again). I think I'm mostly after a classic P-into-B15 sound, only supercharged (hot pickup into Mesa Buster! 200 1x15" combo).
A bit of both. For a different sound, I like my Ibanez ATKs (early models, both 4- and 5-string); those have serviceable 3-band preamps, but I barely use the EQ. That's part of what attracted me to Lace pickups. I have a Lace Aluma-P in the instrument in my avatar and love it, which led me to get my hopes up (and subsequently dashed) about using the 5-string arrangement shown in their wiring diagram. I also have a stock Westone Spectrum GT with one of those crazy hot '80s Japanese P-in-a-bar arrangement, and I think that does the supercharged P thing well; it doesn't have the low end of the Aluma-P, but it has noticeably more than the stock Squier pickup as currently installed.
If the SD QP still sounds like a P but with more lows, that just might work.
Ah: if I wanted soapbars, I could have found a suitable bass with those much more easily and wouldn't think of getting one of these only to modify it beyond recognition. I have a Spector Legend 5 Classic, and I don't think I've ever owned a better looking or better playing instrument, but none of the sounds I get out of it sound like "me." I had the Tone Pump Jr preamp removed and Lace Alumitone soapbars installed, and still. I needed a 5-string Precision, and I want it to sound like it ... just moreso.
The stock pickup screws are made of something that resembles swiss cheese.
So it wasn't just me, haha/groan.
If the hole was stripped, rather than the screw, grab the white glue and some toothpicks...
Just the screw ... so far ...
If it's impossible to get even levels with this setup, then you'll know that you've got a defective pickup half, and can proceed accordingly.
I don't mean to overstate the imbalance between strings as currently set up; a lighter attack on the D and G mostly evens things out. I doubt a defect, but also hadn't considered it. Noted.
If you still don't like the character of the tone with a good working pickup and the normal setup, then it may be that a vintage-style Precision V pickup set isn't for you.
I had planned on having the new pickguard (black) and bridge (Hipshot Kickass) and electronics (M&V, not-cheap guts) all installed at once, but with the delay on the M&V, this convinces me to hold off on the electronics and see what I get with the new bridge and adjustments to the stock pickup (assuming somebody can get that totally stripped screw out, haha/groan again). I think I'm mostly after a classic P-into-B15 sound, only supercharged (hot pickup into Mesa Buster! 200 1x15" combo).
The fact that you're tuning to a low G or A, makes me wonder if a.) your other basses are active, or b.) none of them have vintage-wound Precision pickups in them.
A bit of both. For a different sound, I like my Ibanez ATKs (early models, both 4- and 5-string); those have serviceable 3-band preamps, but I barely use the EQ. That's part of what attracted me to Lace pickups. I have a Lace Aluma-P in the instrument in my avatar and love it, which led me to get my hopes up (and subsequently dashed) about using the 5-string arrangement shown in their wiring diagram. I also have a stock Westone Spectrum GT with one of those crazy hot '80s Japanese P-in-a-bar arrangement, and I think that does the supercharged P thing well; it doesn't have the low end of the Aluma-P, but it has noticeably more than the stock Squier pickup as currently installed.
Replacement pickups are limited by the need to stay reasonably true to the original. While Duncan QP's have a fuller low end than stock Squier or Fender Am Std pickups, they still sound like a P.
If the SD QP still sounds like a P but with more lows, that just might work.
If you already have a non-vintage pickup that has served you well on other five string basses (the Nordy Big Single soapbar is one that comes to mind for me), then why not do the obvious?
Ah: if I wanted soapbars, I could have found a suitable bass with those much more easily and wouldn't think of getting one of these only to modify it beyond recognition. I have a Spector Legend 5 Classic, and I don't think I've ever owned a better looking or better playing instrument, but none of the sounds I get out of it sound like "me." I had the Tone Pump Jr preamp removed and Lace Alumitone soapbars installed, and still. I needed a 5-string Precision, and I want it to sound like it ... just moreso.
Last edited:

