• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Squier Vintage Modified Precision V: who's got one?

Spent about 2 hours with a red one this afternoon. Impressions:
- Easily 2lb lighter than a Sterling Sub Ray 5, about 1lb more than similar Squier 4-strings (VM fretless P, and VM PJ). I would guess mid-to-high 9lb range?
- Mildly head-heavy, but not to the point of excessive neck dive.
- Nut width is 1 7/8". Same as a Fender ADJV, not super-wide like some of the earlier Squier 5-strings.
- Neck profile is a fairly deep C, not shallow like the ADJV.
- Neck is finished in thick gloss poly, same dipped-in-plastic feel as the CV basses.
- Overall quality was excellent. Tidy fret work, tight neck pocket, no finish flaws.
- The neck had a nice, even flame figure. Not bad for a cheap bass!
Only weak spot noted: the pickup screws on the lower pickup half were bottomed out badly. I didn't dare adjust the B-string side with the dealer's crappy screwdriver.
- Setup was good out of the box. Caveats: the B and E strings were a hair low, and the pickups were poorly adjusted, making them sound unbalanced.
- The classic Fender dead spot around the 5th to 7th frets on the G string was missing.
- The bridge felt solid.
- The pickups were hot overall.
- Noise was non-existent, suggesting that the shielding is good.

Straight off the wall, the sound was a little indistinct. The B-string had poor pitch definition on the lowest 3 frets, and digging hard caused fret rattle. The A string sounded low in level and a little hollow, plus the D and G strings were too loud.

The dealer let me make a couple of quick adjustments, tweaking the pickup height and raising the B string slightly. This was enough to smooth out the response, and make the B string sound a lot better.

Tone was in the same ballpark as a MIM 4-string P that I compared it to. The tone control had a useful range, and worked quite smoothly. The pickups had slightly less midrange detail and more bottom than my favourite vintage winds (AVRI '62's and Nordstrands).

Feel-wise, I'm not big on thick gloss finishes. Still, the string spacing, action height, etc., were comparable to an American Standard P-Bass. I could gig this thing without even a string change, and I've never said that about a Squier before.

An interesting sidenote on weight: While checking out other Squiers around it, I noted that the solid-colour basses were all heavier than the sunbursts. We're not talking about an ounce or two, probably closer to a pound overall.

Anybody care to comment on whether this is luck of the draw, or something to do with the lumber they choose for the sunburst bodies?

I asked them to order a sunburst VMP5 on spec. If it sounds as good as the one I tried today and comes in around the 9lb mark, I will likely buy it.

I've got a few recording dates coming up the next while, and I've already been warned to expect some pushback over my Dingwall. I hate playing 4-string house basses, and I'm hoping that it might satisfy the requirement for a passive Fender. Even if it turns out to need better pickup, it could still represent a decent recording bass for small coin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iceboxbass
Despite what the specs page claims, I'm thinking that the sunbursts (talking about the sunburst VM Jazz and P-bass fretless models and the VMP PJ as well) are Agathis, not Basswood.

IMO this is a reasonable assumption, given the figure and grain patterns that I've seen, along with the weights quoted.

I'm down with this, as long as they can be made to sound as good as the Jazz I recently slapped a pair of Dimarzio Area J's into. That thing was crazy light (8lb 4oz), and sounded great...
 
Just pulled the trigger on a used sunburst from musiciansfriend. Should be here on Thursday. I've tried and failed to get used to fivers a few times but I'll give it another shot, though there's a good chance there'll be a squier p5 in the classifieds in about a week.
 
Bummed.

Tried a CAR P5 at Long and McQuade and liked it. But it was well over 9lb, so I asked them to get me a sunburst on approval.

Just got the word that it won't be in until mid-December.

Meanwhile, there's an 8lb 13oz TSB at Sweetwater. I would ignore the fact that the body parts are poorly matched, but shipping is $70-odd each way...
 
Bah. Found another CAR at a different branch.



Much lighter. Looked and sounded just as good as the first, but had a mild dead spot at the C on the G string, that progressed into a wicked one at the C#.



Bracing the headstock against the side of a nearby speaker cab tamed it nicely, but I don't really want to put the effort into fiddling with tungsten weights or a Fatfinger to fix a dead spot when I'm not totally sold on the colour.
 
My American P5 is my go-to, desert island bass. I'd like a white Squier P5 as a backup and to put flats on. Hopefully I can get a good price on one here when someone decides they can't bond with a fiver. Or else Sweetwater has a sale (they post weights and 9 lbs is pretty much my limit). Being retired and in a new band, discretionary $ and gigging funds are hard to come by :(
 
Well, today was the day... or rather tonight after I got off work.

Unboxed her, loosed the strings and made 1/4 turn of the truss rod to get the relief at .10, set the action at just a smidgen above 1/16th of an inch, and bam!

This bass sounds good through the little 20 watt practice amp and I can't wait to get it to church tomorrow to hear it though the bigger rig and PA system. The only complaint I have is the strings... I'm just not a rounds guy and the stock strings aren't for me. After I get my preferred set on this baby I'm sure it will become my go to instrument. It plays every bit as well as my Spector NS-95, and has that split coil passive tone that I love.

She weighs in at 9.4 lbs. and I got really lucky with the body... nary a visible join. You can see one on the back, but on the front it's nearly invisible.

Being the tinker that I am I'm sure at some point I'll upgrade the electronics, but I'm in no big hurry. Here's a pic, although it isn't that great... my iPhone is all I have.
 
I may pull the trigger on a burst P, pending a play and a listen. My local store got both the P and J5 in so I went in for a fiddle today. Regrettably the P had already sold. I really liked the J5 but they've lost themselves my custom purely because it fails to come in burst. I don't like any of the solid finishes in the J5. They look corny and cheap and the only tone that appeals is the Olympic which I don't love.

So they're getting another candy red in next week and they're going to call me when it's in so I can have a crack. I was told that the necks are identical but I never buy anything without playing it. If I dig the tone of the P I'll just go ahead and order one I think. The price is simply stupid.

Can you guys confirm that the neck on the P is the same as the J. I can see it is on spec but are there any quirks between the 2.

Also are there any real differences between the solids and the burst. Some people seem to indicate that it's lighter? Is the tone affected by this?
 
She's a looker! Glad you got one with decent bookmatching.


Well, today was the day... or rather tonight after I got off work.

Unboxed her, loosed the strings and made 1/4 turn of the truss rod to get the relief at .10, set the action at just a smidgen above 1/16th of an inch, and bam!

This bass sounds good through the little 20 watt practice amp and I can't wait to get it to church tomorrow to hear it though the bigger rig and PA system. The only complaint I have is the strings... I'm just not a rounds guy and the stock strings aren't for me. After I get my preferred set on this baby I'm sure it will become my go to instrument. It plays every bit as well as my Spector NS-95, and has that split coil passive tone that I love.

She weighs in at 9.4 lbs. and I got really lucky with the body... nary a visible join. You can see one on the back, but on the front it's nearly invisible.

Being the tinker that I am I'm sure at some point I'll upgrade the electronics, but I'm in no big hurry. Here's a pic, although it isn't that great... my iPhone is all I have.