Tried out a guitar player yesterday. It went OK, not great.
He can play fine and mostly was able to jam along with the drummer and I. He had some equipment issues, but I'm chalking that up to playing through an amp that wasn't his. I had some issues too, I think the preamp tube in my LH1000 is going south, was getting some volume/output swings.
The guy was just a little weird. He told us right off the bat that he's not a songwriter. I said " That's fine, neither am I, but we could collaborate. I'd rather do that than have a singer-songwriter show up with a notebook full of songs."
So we jammed on a couple of my riffs/basslines and the skeleton of a song that I've put together and that all went ok. Getting tired of my material, I asked him if he's got some riffs or ideas. Nope. Nothing at all. He replied with: "I never said I had any ideas".
...ok.
So I'm thinking it's a no go, I don't have the time to be primary songwriter for everything the band does. I was hoping for a more organic back-and-forth collaboration in the jam room but it wasn't there. Yes, it was the first time that we'd met the guy and things could get better - but if I'm going to be met with blank stares and silence every time I'm looking for input then I don't think it's going to work. Andrew (drummer) can offer suggestions, but he only plays drums, no guitar or anything like that so it's tough for him to come up with riffs or song ideas.
I'm debating whether or not to give it another try with the dude, but I don't know...