So, I've been bouncing my way through the 3 amps and right now I'm leaning toward the fender. The Eden is great, but it's features aren't really a good fit for me. I have a compressor I love, the enhance just scoops in a way I came easily do myself, and the bass boost (while more useful than a typical bass boost because it's more of a parametric thing not just a dB boost} is something I could get with a preamp, or a solid dialing in of a lot of amps. The blackstar is great, but I just feel like it's already 2/3 of the way to the modeling amp anyway. The fender plays nicer with my current equipment in that it will independently power an extension, and it's good for transcription because I'm having an easier time dialing in a match to what I'm working on.
The eden did have a great layout, and the blackstar is the most flexible non-modeling amp I've ever seen. They're all great. (BTW,I know I may have sort of been flexible with the definition of "modeling amp," but I think my point still stands.)
I'm shipping out the "losers," tomorrow, so one more night to wow.
Sounds as if you’re giving all three a fair shakedown. Let your ears do the final deciding, but I don’t believe you’ll come out on the wrong side, no matter which way you go.
I think you’ll agree with many of us that Fender made a serious attempt at bringing the modeling amplifier to a new level of tone and quality build. The Stage 800 will be my final modeler and I feel it’s a worthy partner in medium to large gigs.
Enjoyed the commentary, Rhaco, keep up the fine reporting.

