I was confused about the opening post. Like is that supposed to be a bad thing? It's an SG bass. That's what it's supposed to do. If a bass VI sounds like "twang," you don't get mad at it. It's working like it should. Besides, I know for a fact that those basses are capable of at least three distinct tones, just like any other two-pickup bass is. Neck, bridge, and neck+bridge. I don't think I've ever played a bass, SG ones included, that sounded exactly the same on all pickups.
Reading further, it seems the only appreciable defense anyone could give on the first two pages was "oh no, you can't possibly play your Gibson bass hard, it will sound awful!" Thereby insulting anyone who does play a Gibson/Epiphone with aggressive plucking/picking technique. Like **** you, dude, I'll play my bass how I damn well please.
Well, since I am a bassist who does have a sound geared towards cutting through the mix, and I like my basses to sound clanky, I'm forbidden to say what I would like to by the TB forum rules. Let's be honest about what we're talking about when we say "cut through the mix," though. What we really mean by "mix" is "the guitar(s)." At least in my world. And cutting through just means finding a frequency where I can both be clearly heard and not have to overpower everything with sheer volume. If I wanted to just narcissistically dominate everything, it would be called "drowning out the mix" or "pushing over the mix."
Also, **** "blending seamlessly." If we as a band "blend seamlessly," then we have failed and wrote separate parts for no reason. Yes, there are parts that we want to be like an indistinguishable wall of sound coming at the listener, but that's not most of the time. Are the parts written for the various instruments supposed to fit together? Sure. But they're not supposed to completely blend together so that you can't tell that they're the interaction of more than one part. Otherwise instead of having a bassist, two guitarists, and keyboardist/3rd guitarist, we could just have one guitarist with four amps and an octave pedal.
Maybe I'm being a bit salty, but after the first person to speak up that maybe there's nothing wrong with the SG Bass also pretty directly insulted how I sound by saying that aggressively playing on one of my basses must sound "awful" since I'm not petting it gently like a newborn kitten, and others chiming in, like yourself that any clanky bass sounds like poopiee, I'm a bit peeved. And it hurts when I breathe.
Who?