I like a lot of PF stuff, I dislike Watters personally but like his contributions (as well as the other band members contributions) when the whole band was together.
A lot of the early albums are hit and miss with me. Pipers has a couple of good songs as do some of the other pre DSOM albums, but for me DSOM, Wish You Were Here, and The Wall were all life changing albums in my very formative social and musical years (early to late teens). Any one of those three albums were a listening experience for me. Rarely did I play one or two tracks of them, I'd almost always play them front to back. I can't say that about many other bands albums at the time. When Division Bell came out in the 1990's it was like a flashback to the seventies and although not quite as moving as the earlier stuff it was very true to the 1970's album formula with a good flow from beginning to end. It was the final chapter in the PF saga for me. The David Gilmour "On an Island" album was pretty Floydesque also, but quite a bit more laid back than most of the PF works.
All in all, PF was probably in the top three of my favorite bands to listen to in the 1970's. Beat the snot out of what my girl friends at the time always wanted to hear - Abba, The BeeGees, Neil Sadaka and Rod Stewart (a trip to the dentist would be more enjoyable).