Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Who's the better slapper: Flea or Les Claypool?
- Thread starter Tupac
- Start date
Whilst I agree a direct comparison is nigh on impossible, I can't see how Flea is 'more musical' or has 'more groove'. Claypool has a groove all of his own that most of his peers cannot touch. If you know his work, you know what I mean. If you don't, well go and listen to Spaghetti Western (as one of many examples) and come back and tell me that doesn't groove like a mofo 
Flea slaps perfectly well enough, and his slapping really drives the Chili Peppers grooves. Hard.
But Claypool is more original - does some stuff with fretless slapping/sliding that nobody else does.
But Claypool is more original - does some stuff with fretless slapping/sliding that nobody else does.
rockstarbassist
Inactive
In the "traditional" basic slap n pop style, Flea has a better, cleaner technique.
I don't really consider Les a huge slapper anyway as most of his stuff is strums, chords, taps and pops as opposed to the style Flea plays. Really not even the same thing in a way to be compared.
I don't really consider Les a huge slapper anyway as most of his stuff is strums, chords, taps and pops as opposed to the style Flea plays. Really not even the same thing in a way to be compared.
Way to subjective to even discuss...... One Guy does this better than the other, while the other does this better than the one guy.....
Hold on, what did I just say?
Hold on, what did I just say?
Since when does Les Claypool even make music? I thought all those albums were just him fornicating with his bass with some kind of band behind him 
.
.
Back in 2001 I met a went to a guitar shop in Ohio to buy my old Ampeg BA210 amp (now sold and gone) anyway the owner of the small shop use to be a session guy in LA before he moved back to Ohio to open the shop. He was better than Les and Flea combined hands down, his name was Bill.
Kwesi said:Since when does Les Claypool even make music? I thought all those albums were just him fornicating with his bass with some kind of band behind him
Your smiley gets you off the hook.
Personally I like Claypool, but that's just because something in what he does appeals to my sense of humor. Sometimes just the sound of his playing makes me laugh.
Other than that, can't really compare the two because they serve different purposes.... anyone who expects Les to fill the same role as Flea in a band is missing the whole point of Primus.
Other than that, can't really compare the two because they serve different purposes.... anyone who expects Les to fill the same role as Flea in a band is missing the whole point of Primus.
I'm going to set up a battle of the bands to determine the answer to this. Whomever sells the most tickets, Flea or Les, gets to determine which time slot they get. Winner advances to the second round for a chance to win $500 and 20hrs of studio time.
Thefunkymonk said:
Sorry, red wine is far better, even though I like a cold Sauvignon Blanc or a Riesling from time to time!
