• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Why do people discrimanate?

Originally posted by MJ5150
So, you are telling me that there is ZERO potential that the straight guy will have more in common with me? Lets see....the straight guy likes to have sex with women, the gay guy won't. If I am at the bar to find a date for the night, the gay guy isn't there for that reason. I have to agree with you somewhat about it having little effect on a persons life outside of bedroom preferences, but what you said at first is ridiculous.


well, since i did not type that there is "ZERO potential that the straight guy will have more in common with you" then i obviously did not tell you that. Durrrrr.
I said, there is no point in assuming that you will have more in common with mr heterosexual than with mr homosexual, because that might not, and probably will not be the case.

In conclusion, you are wrong, i am right. As always.
 
Originally posted by DeepDeath
Their is a difference between morals, and civility and humanism. Not associating yourself with others is discrimination as clearly as "White People Only" signs to a Swastika tattoed deeply black into your breast. Stop your Jim Crow morals.


Not associating myself with them means I'm descriminating against them? Please. I don't have to associate myself with others for your's or anybody else's approval.

I don't have many black friends, better watch out then cause I MUST be a racist and in the KKK, or at least my father is or something. I don't have many hispanic friends either, boy I must be filled with hate!

I've dated a bi girl once, and I'm good friends with another, but I don't hate them. I just strongly disagree with their lifestyle choices. IS IT SO WRONG TO DISAGREE WITH A CERTAIN LIFESTYLE? You disagree with mine, and I'll disagree with theirs.

And so, if me not associating with homosexuals is your definition of me being descriminatory, then paint me descriminatory. Paint a billboard and tell all your friends I'm a bigot. If thats your definition of one, call me that as much as you like. I really don't care how much of a bigot you may think I am. You'd be the first to ever call me one. I'm not changing for you or anybody else.

I have a set of morals and belief standards. I have no problem with other's morals and beliefs as long as they are respectful of mine. But if you want to attack me for those (like comparing my beliefs to Jim Crow laws), get bent.
 
Originally posted by jrthebassguy
Not associating myself with them means I'm descriminating against them? Please. I don't have to associate myself with others for your's or anybody else's approval.

I don't have many black friends, better watch out then cause I MUST be a racist and in the KKK, or at least my father is or something. I don't have many hispanic friends either, boy I must be filled with hate!

I've dated a bi girl once, and I'm good friends with another, but I don't hate them. I just strongly disagree with their lifestyle choices. IS IT SO WRONG TO DISAGREE WITH A CERTAIN LIFESTYLE? You disagree with mine, and I'll disagree with theirs.

And so, if me not associating with homosexuals is your definition of me being descriminatory, then paint me descriminatory. Paint a billboard and tell all your friends I'm a bigot. If thats your definition of one, call me that as much as you like. I really don't care how much of a bigot you may think I am. You'd be the first to ever call me one. I'm not changing for you or anybody else.

I have a set of morals and belief standards. I have no problem with other's morals and beliefs as long as they are respectful of mine. But if you want to attack me for those (like comparing my beliefs to Jim Crow laws), get bent.


Same here...


I don't have a lot of hispanic friends, because the hispanic kids around here are all into the gangster lifestyle... I have some friends in that group who have that lifestyle that i hang out with at school, but I wouldn't go out one night with them cause I dont know what they would do...


EDIT:

I just realized I made an awful stereotype...

I meant to say, a whole lot of the hispanic kids at my school are into that lifestyle, and the other ones, I just never really am around... no classes with or anything.
 
The very idea that they're doing something wrong is a judgement.

Saying that someone does something wrong is not judging. Let me say that again. Saying that someone does something wrong is not judging. For example, a cop pulls you over and tells you you were speeding. Can you say "how could you judge me like that?" No, that wouldn't make sense.
If you say that judging is merely commenting on what a person does, then it's judging to say "dang, that kid's good at basketball." Do you see my point?
 
Originally posted by greenbassfreak
What is the point of discrimanation does it make people feel better about them selfs?

yeah, that, and also to help save them the effort of actually trying to maintain an open mind. it's a hard thing to do for some people. heck, let's face it, we all have our petty prejudices - i can't stand wishnevsky basses, for instance :D. on the other hand, steve wishnevsky is an awesome writer, i'd love to read more of his work.
 
Originally posted by clef360
Saying that someone does something wrong is not judging. Let me say that again. Saying that someone does something wrong is not judging. For example, a cop pulls you over and tells you you were speeding. Can you say "how could you judge me like that?" No, that wouldn't make sense.
If you say that judging is merely commenting on what a person does, then it's judging to say "dang, that kid's good at basketball." Do you see my point?

actually saying something is "wrong" implies a moral judgement. the cop saying "you were speeding" implies the morality of a speeding law - that it is somehow morally wrong to go about a certain speed limit in your vehicle.
 
Originally posted by MJ5150
Brad.....let me get this straight....if I disagree with someones lifestyle, I am judging them? That is complete BS. I guess if we continue using your logic, no one is allowed to have different opinions, or disagree with anyone. We all must agree all the time. Otherwise we would be a judgmental bigot?

Hey, I'm calling it like I'm reading it. Is this or is this not a judgement:

" My moral guidelines tell me it is improper."

Sounds like a judgement to me. Still say it's BS? Heck, I'm making a judgement based on what you've said so far... the difference is I'm not going to pretend it's not what it is... a judgement:D

And you obviously can't continue using my logic, you don't seem to get what I'm saying.

I understand better what you mean about social groups I associate with. There are ZERO social groups I avoid because I feel they are "wrong". Since we are talking primarily about homosexual/heterosexual, I will continue on that subject. I walk into a room, and see one man identify himself as "gay", and another identify himself as "straight". I am initially drawn to the "straight" person since there is more POTENTIAL of us having more things in common. Would I rule out the "gay" person as a friend? No, I would not. But the chances of me having more in common with the "straight" guy are higher. Just like if I walk into a room with my wife and kids, and see one couple with kids, and a couple with no kids. We are drawn to the couple whom we would naturally have more in common with, the ones with kids. The same is true the other way around. Childless couples naturally tend to associate with other childless couples. Are these folks ignorant, closet bigots? Hardly. Having kids is a definite lifestyle choice. I chose to have kids, some don't. I certainly do NOT condemn anyone who remains childless.


Sadly enough, snap judgements like these IMO keep the world from being a better place.

Why on Earth would you automatically think you'd have more in common with either man? That makes as much sense as me walking into a room and thinking I'll have more in common with someone of my race. That's just plain small-minded. People who do this tend to be pretty narrow-minded and this does nothing to remedy that situation IME.

Talk to people, meet INDIVIDUALS, that's what it SHOULD be about. You'll never understand the other side by working in a box. And I said understand, not relish, promote, admire, whatever.

As silly as the scenario of two men id'ing themselves by sexuality when you walk into a room is, let's run with it. You of course may be different but as far as myself the only thing I know I don't have in common with the gay man is sexuality. If that gay man were a musician and the straight one was a cokehead accountant, still think you'd have more in common? I wouldn't.

The couples thing is no less weak. Because a couple has their kids with them you'd be drawn to them? How do you know the other couple wouldn't be more interesting? By your logic you'd never know because again you're too wrapped up in stereotypes to deal with actual human beings. Your loss.

How do you know the other couple's kids weren't somewhere else? Oh, that's right, talking to them would've drawn that info out and you're tied up with your preferred, "obvious" choice.

My wife and I associate with people and call me crazy but it never occurred to me to only gravitate to people just like us. I guess we're just more outgoing and interested in diversity. It's not like kids are the only thing we can talk about;)


DavyO....Could you direct me to the evidence please? I have been unable to find it. Are you simply repeating things you have heard, or do you know where to find this?

C'mon, is there any evidence that you'd actually accept?

Seriously.

"Not associating yourself with others is discrimination"..................***? Explain please.

-Mike

If you're basing it on a pre-conceived stereotypical notion, what would you call it?
 
Originally posted by BrokenAngel
That is bs. I'm sorry but it is....
Unless you believe in the stereotypical gay person (which you obviously do), you just wouldn't assume that you would have more in common with a straight person than a gay person, just because of their sexual orientation.
There are plenty gay parents who vote conservative, buy guns and eat lots of red meat, just as there are white parents who vote green, buy fair trade coffee and live in eco friendly communes. I'm sure you'de have much more in common with the gay person then.
Sexual orientation has no effect on personality, hobbies, interests or any other aspects of life, apart from bedroom ones. It would do you good to remember this.

Brad - i love you :p

I love you too.

It's amazing how unpopular open minds seem to be getting these days:D

It's damn near robotic sometimes...

See person
Assume their qualities
Shun or engage based on assumption of qualities vs. own values
Miss out on 90% of the really cool people out there because of the stereotypes in your program.

The sad thing is that very few people are forced to act this way... it's learned and/or voluntary.
 
Originally posted by MJ5150
So, you are telling me that there is ZERO potential that the straight guy will have more in common with me? Lets see....the straight guy likes to have sex with women, the gay guy won't.

Possibly true. Now, what exactly is the relevancebetween you and either of the men's sexual partners?

If I am at the bar to find a date for the night, the gay guy isn't there for that reason. I have to agree with you somewhat about it having little effect on a persons life outside of bedroom preferences, but what you said at first is ridiculous.

See, I just learned something. I had no idea that only straight people go to bars to find dates.

Mike. Think. Especially if you're going to toss the word "ridiculous" around:D

This is exactly what I figured would happen. I speak up in this thread and express how I feel about it, and everyone jumps on the PC bandwagon and tries to beat me down for being a bigot. I am not allowed to disagree, that makes me judgemental. I am a bigot for ASSUMING a straight guy would share more in common with me than a gay guy. My opinions are now BS.

-Mike

Mike, it's a seriously weak assumption. A big part of the problem is that you don't seem to know what you don't know.

This isn't about being PC but if that gives you a warm and fuzzy feelin', cool. It's about not stereotyping. You can disagree with whatever you want. I just happen to disagree with you. I've heard what you're saying a million times and fortunately sometimes people actually realize that the rock hard mindset they've been working under needed be so hard.

Things that make sense usally aren't real difficult to explain. OTOH the stuff with holes is a real bear:D
 
Originally posted by Brad Johnson
I love you too.

It's amazing how unpopular open minds seem to be getting these days:D

It's damn near robotic sometimes...

See person
Assume their qualities
Shun or engage based on assumption of qualities vs. own values
Miss out on 90% of the really cool people out there because of the stereotypes in your program.

The sad thing is that very few people are forced to act this way... it's learned and/or voluntary.

totally :(
It makes me really sad to see people missing out on so much, and contributing to the sadly growing culture of hate and self inflicted segregation.
 
Originally posted by clef360
Saying that someone does something wrong is not judging. Let me say that again. Saying that someone does something wrong is not judging. For example, a cop pulls you over and tells you you were speeding. Can you say "how could you judge me like that?" No, that wouldn't make sense.
If you say that judging is merely commenting on what a person does, then it's judging to say "dang, that kid's good at basketball." Do you see my point?

Frankly, no

:D

I'm sure you had one. You even wrote it twice.


How can saying someone did something wrong NOT be a judgement? What would you call it?

And one last one, what would you call a judgment?

TIA
 
Originally posted by john turner
actually saying something is "wrong" implies a moral judgement. the cop saying "you were speeding" implies the morality of a speeding law - that it is somehow morally wrong to go about a certain speed limit in your vehicle.

No, the cop isn't implying anything about the morality of the speeding law, he's merely saying that you were wrong in terms of the standard (which is the state law). In the same way I can say that someone is wrong for say, stealing, since it's wrong according to my standards. Other people might not think that stealing is wrong, and I'm not attacking their beliefs, I'm merely voicing mine. "Tolerance" means that people are allowed to have their own opinions and voice them how they want, right?