• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Dirt pedals that kill your highs?

As my tastes get a little more refined, I am finding that pedals that kill my top end bite are not my cup of tea. I know we're bassists and are mainly concerned about keeping the lows in our dirt, but for me, the highs should not be sacrificed. Nothing makes my playing feel better than having that nice zip on the highs, especially when I can control it with playing dynamics and how I attack the strings. I hate pedals that I feel like I have to fight to get more zip. More than a few of my recent acquisitions seem to be very lacking in treble, and have since gone on Reverb.com.

I am wondering what the general consensus is around here on treble bite in a dirt pedal, good, bad or indifferent?

I find most dirt pedals kill low end and not high end
 
  • Like
Reactions: franvarin and MGR
As my tastes get a little more refined, I am finding that pedals that kill my top end bite are not my cup of tea. I know we're bassists and are mainly concerned about keeping the lows in our dirt, but for me, the highs should not be sacrificed. Nothing makes my playing feel better than having that nice zip on the highs, especially when I can control it with playing dynamics and how I attack the strings. I hate pedals that I feel like I have to fight to get more zip. More than a few of my recent acquisitions seem to be very lacking in treble, and have since gone on Reverb.com.

I am wondering what the general consensus is around here on treble bite in a dirt pedal, good, bad or indifferent?

I use a darkglass b7k ultra, darkglass duality fuzz, and sans amp RBI for all my dirt needs.
I reallying don't think losing highs is an issue with any of them. I don't boost highs on anything at any point in my chain. I do tend to use the filter knob to cut some of the highs on the duality. But that's mainly because running direct to foh can mean way too much treble coming out of the PA. The filter does a good job of fixing that problem without mutilating my fuzz tone and making it sound like someone through a blanket over all the speakers in the venue.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MGR and gregmon79
Treble bite is a must for me. No question. I almost never have an issue with it though because of my preamp setup. Mainly the B7KU and the rusty box. Adds all the brightness I could want. I guess I've tried some dirt pedals that are dark but then again not really. My pork loin was a little too dark for me pre mod. Then I modded it and bam, perfection. For me anyway. I love that bright a$$ dirt pedal. Plus again, I run all my preamps, onboard EQ and such bright. Never really had that problem. I get all the top end zing and bite I want/need. So just about anything I get nowadays works for me. Almost. But you get pedals like the fuzzro rat tail, big game F800b or even my SUF civil unrest and I'm golden with those. A tone control usually works quite well for retaining high end......which a ton of dirt pedal have....
 
Boss MT-2 kills everything but the top which it will turn into the famous attack of the anemic killer bees sound :p

And that was not meant in any nice way, unless of course you are a sucker for fizzling sounds. :thumbsup:

(Strangely enough though, it sounds beautiful, on the right settings, stacked in front of an EHX Tube Zipper used a fuzz, which it turns into an over the top, out of control doom machine of highly sophisticated mud with interesting velvet grain structures and tons of soothing overtones).
 
Last edited:
I'm not too big on dirt myself although I'm perfectly comfortable admitting it does have its uses.

About the only pedal that doesn't kill the bottom (and which I actually like) is the VHT V-Drive. It has enough adjustable parameters that if you can't find anything in there that'll work for you - then you probably don't like dirt at all.
 
As my tastes get a little more refined, I am finding that pedals that kill my top end bite are not my cup of tea. I know we're bassists and are mainly concerned about keeping the lows in our dirt, but for me, the highs should not be sacrificed. Nothing makes my playing feel better than having that nice zip on the highs, especially when I can control it with playing dynamics and how I attack the strings. I hate pedals that I feel like I have to fight to get more zip. More than a few of my recent acquisitions seem to be very lacking in treble, and have since gone on Reverb.com.

I am wondering what the general consensus is around here on treble bite in a dirt pedal, good, bad or indifferent?

Have you tried the Route 66 pedal? Mine looks different than the current model I see advertised, it looks like the builder's name may have changed, but if they work the same, I simply haven't found a better bass OD pedal. You don't lose the highs or lows (there's a low switch on it in fact). Sound guys have actually applauded it when they heard it, they're used to hearing such awful results with bass distortion. I'm serious, at a gig, a sound guy applauded during sound check, and I got many other compliments over the years.

This may be a little controversial, but the Korg pandora PX5D actually does an incredible job with distortion, and just about everything else, and sounds great recorded- I'm really glad I got one of those before they were discontinued, it's great for guitar and bass in the studio. You can find them on eBay from time to time. And there's no reason you couldn't use it live. You may think it's silly to use a little cassette sized AA battery powered box for professional recording, but I swear I once used it instead of an actual B-15 flip top that was too noisy to record, and a few weeks later the mastering engineer on the project said I was his new favorite bass player. Although I bet he says that to all the bass players ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: MGR
Sound like you might want to try the CA Labs Grizzly. Not a ripping distortion but a good overdrive, it has seperate OD and Distortion controls for two different sounds, and then it has a hi cut and a mids cut circuit, so you can take out what you want.
 
Is anyone else out there finding that the SFX Beta cuts their highs? Even with the tone knob dimed all the way to the treble side it seems to cut my highs unlike any other dirt pedal I've used. I've been sticking with it because the breakup sounds so good but I wish it wasn't so dark.
 
Is anyone else out there finding that the SFX Beta cuts their highs? Even with the tone knob dimed all the way to the treble side it seems to cut my highs unlike any other dirt pedal I've used. I've been sticking with it because the breakup sounds so good but I wish it wasn't so dark.

Yes, that's its whole intention, to be a vintage-sounding overdrive, which involves a good amount of top end rolloff. I agree, the breakup/saturation of the Beta is my favorite ever in an overdrive pedal...big saturated sound on the lows while maintaining a crunch instead of a compressed/fart sound in the breakup. I found myself wanting more treble content form the original, as well. This, I'm guessing, is the main reason they introduced the LM308 version of the Beta, which I now own and love. It still has that big low end of the regular Beta, but the LM308 chip gives it more range on the top end. It's awesome.

The new Beta DLX (that I haven't tried yet due to xmas timing) also expands the range of the original Beta to address all of that and more. You can apparently get the best of the original , LM308 and Germanium versions plus more in that box. SolidgoldFX will even make an LM308 version of the DLX.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jj4001
Very true. It's amazing really how many people still don't realize that the frequency spectrum exists and needs to be thought of and respected if a band is to sound good.

Beyond not realizing it exists, many are in active denial. I kind of get guitarists being dicks about their tone and that being a pain in the mix. But my main drummer has a mic installed in his kickdrum and insists on running through the PA all of the time. He looks at me like I suggested dinosaurs were on the ark whenever I tell him he's washing out or over-resonating my lows.

Related, I get snarky comments about all of my "effects" pedals and how often I swap them out all the time...when in reality 5 out of the 7 pedals on my working gig board are just EQ of some sort to help me fit into the mix at different times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tourniquet Man
Beyond not realizing it exists, many are in active denial. I kind of get guitarists being dicks about their tone and that being a pain in the mix. But my main drummer has a mic installed in his kickdrum and insists on running through the PA all of the time. He looks at me like I suggested dinosaurs were on the ark whenever I tell him he's washing out or over-resonating my lows.

Related, I get snarky comments about all of my "effects" pedals and how often I swap them out all the time...when in reality 5 out of the 7 pedals on my working gig board are just EQ of some sort to help me fit into the mix at different times.
I know how it is. When I was a drummer (but one that knew about the freq. spectrum) I was in a band that split up because of this issue. The bassist was futzing around onstage with his sound that wasn't working in the room. I simply went over to his amp eq, fixed the problem in 3 seconds and we did the show with no further problems. Later in the band room he took me to task for "touching his amp." Well, it started a chain reaction that led to that band breaking up, which was a shame for me personally because I loved playing with that group. If band members would just discuss their place in the frequency spectrum, I think world peace would be achieved!