• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Do you play what they play?

The guy who inspired me to play bass (Steve Swallow, in the way long ago) was playing a double-bass, an instrument at which I am embarrassingly bad. So...no. (And he was playing jazz, a style at which I am an eternal beginner, so double-whammy there)
 
  • Like
Reactions: FlatwoundFunk
No. The one time I tried to play the same bass a musical hero was in the mid-seventies, when I bought a Gibson EB-3. I love Jack Bruce and I loved the way that bass looked, but it did not work for me.

The guy who inspired me to play bass (Steve Swallow, in the way long ago) was playing a double-bass, an instrument at which I am embarrassingly bad. So...no.
Interesting that you should mention Steve Swallow. I have spent years chasing the sound he got when he was playing a Fender in the early 1980s (he played a P bass with Hi-A P and J pickups, if I remember correctly).
 
I bought my first fretless P because of Percy Jones, and my 4001 because of Chris Squire- those basses are long gone. I still play fretless, but have moved to 5ers, and more "off" brands. My goal now is to sound like me, not someone else who happens to use the same gear (and may be famous).
 
  • Like
Reactions: FlatwoundFunk
No. The one time I tried to play the same bass a musical hero was in the mid-seventies, when I bought a Gibson EB-3. I love Jack Bruce and I loved the way that bass looked, but it did not work for me.


Interesting that you should mention Steve Swallow. I have spent years chasing the sound he got when he was playing a Fender in the early 1980s (he played a P bass with Hi-A P and J pickups, if I remember correctly).

Yeah, that was a killer sound.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RHFusillo
Kinda, except right side up.
IMG_0324-Version2.jpg


dPPOV.jpg
 
Yes, on several accounts. One is purely coincidence, one is intentional, and a custom build I just recently commissioned from Alembic shares specs with several instruments built expressly for a handful of my favorite players. One bass I've had for a while now, literally belonged to one of my (many) bass heroes/influences. They apparently didn't like it as much as I do! ;)
 
Not that I have anything against what my favorites play(ed), but I pick my basses based on how well I think will fit what I'm looking for and I ultimately end up keeping the ones that feel the best to me and give me the sound I want.

I've owned about 15 basses and my current Stingray is by far the best overall bass I've owned. Love the sound and the versatility but it's the feel makes it my favorite. The feel of the neck, the string spacing, the way it hangs on my shoulder, etc. just fit ME perfectly. Some of my bass heroes have played Stingrays but I don't think any of them was known for playing a Stingray.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FlatwoundFunk
I've tried it: I've had a couple Rics (Squire), a Fodera (Wooten), and a couple Modulii (Flea), plus my current bass sounds pretty much like Geddy's Jazz, which is my favorite tone ever, but I'm not tied to a specific bass so long as it gives me Dat Sound.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FlatwoundFunk
Not really. Steve Harris and Geezer Butler both play P basses, but I do play Lakland like Geezer.
I toyed with Warwick basses a little because of the slew of monster metal players they have, but I can't get find the models I want to try, and couldn't afford them if I could.
I play GK and GB out of necessity more than what other people play. I guess I would be playing Hartke or Aguilar if I did.
Aside from Alex Webster using the B3k, which I sold, I don't think I use pedals other players I like use. Oddly I don't like the majority of artists drawn to the pedals I like. Go figure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FlatwoundFunk
I kinda dID the 50/50 thing. Pick up something I got inspired by and flip it around enough to make it my own.

I play a Charvel 2B pointy headstock because I loved the Jackson that David Ellefson has. The problem was that the 4-string Jacksons have a small pointy headstock whereas the old 4-string Charvel models have the same big headstock as the 5-string Jacksons.
Invalid Link Removed

I now play a Killer Dagger because I loved the Akira Takasaki (LOUDNESS) / Taiji (X-JAPAN, LOUDNESS) styled (bass)guitars but have thrown in Villex P/J to "claim" my own signature sound.
Egk4DNz.jpg

Invalid Link Removed

Man, I dig that "killer dagger" bass!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jeffrey Bryan
Do you play the same brand or style of bass that your favorite bassist plays? I mean the players who most inspired you to pick up the instrument .

Yes, I mean no, well... sort of... not really.

My bass hero as a kid was Dennis Dunaway. He has played mostly a Fender Jazz bass over the years. Another favorite player of mine was Donald Duck Dunn who played some version of a P-bass for the most part. Leland Sklar is another player that influenced me a bunch. He has played a ton of different basses over the years.

I play mostly P-basses, with or without flats. My Rickenbacker gets a lot of love from me as well. This is because I like the sound that I can get out of them.

So the real answer is that although my favorite players may have influenced me to play and made me curious about their particular instruments, I play what suits me.
 
Do you play the same brand or style of bass that your favorite bassist plays?

Nope. Not at all.

And to be honest, except for a brief period when I was in high school (when I was totally enamored of Chris Squire & Jon Camp and so wanted a Rickenbacker 4001 desperately), it's never even occurred to me to get the same bass as what my favorite players use.

Okay, perhaps that's not entirely true: I've certainly lusted for a Wal like Mick Karn's, a Fodera like Anthony Jackson's, an Alembic like Stanley Clarke's or Jimmy Johnson's, an F Bass like Alain Caron's, and if I had the wherewithal I would own all those basses in a heartbeat...but not because those guys play those basses, but rather because those basses are totally badass.


Hmm...well, there was a brief period in the early 80s when Tony Levin played a Steinberger L-2, and I happen to own a Steinberger L-2 that I got in 1982 which I suppose if I thought about it hard enough I might concede that I bought in part because of Tony's endorsement.

But mostly, nope.