I find with saxophones that the scooped sits well.
My son is a professional bass player and embarking on sound engineering. He is now under way with a qualified engineer and he is now in his own session occasionally recording bands
He was recently explaining to me about some problems with low mids on bass guitars in a front of house mix and a studio mix
For my whole life I have stubbornly sat with all settings on flat
We went right over the rumble 200 together on both an American 2012 p and an American 2012 jazz
The 2012 p has a custom shop 62 pickup and it’s output is scooped
The Jazz has 60’s j pups and individually the pus are not scooped
Our impression is that low mids , with everything else rolled off on the rumble 200 on both guitars and across provide a tone range that is not very useable or attractive
The low mids, then when mixed in on a range of tone settings, to us, muddy the tone for want of a better word
The high mids however seem to provide a good tone option
The treble is a bit harsh with the p with guitar tone pots open, but surpringly for us, seemed good on the j with the tone pot open
In offering these comments, it’s just our perspective, my son has played in some pretty aggressive punk whilst I am more old school with 70’s
In later life I have mostly played blues type music and earlier this year hooked up with some jazz people
I have also shyed away from a scooped sound and have been strongly influenced by people and consensus on talkbass. To which I appreciate and respect
I also appreciate issues with being lost in the mix but I took the plunge to explore some different settings after initial discussions with my son
He has also listened and heard me play front if house and I have to say, I am now far from convinced about low mids
He also told me that in spite of what a lot of bass players may insist on, there are plenty of good foh people who wont hesitate to isolate and roll out low mids both live and in studio
I was surprised with all of that.. especially given how many bass players explain the importance of punch and sitting in the mix with emphasis on mids...
At the end of yesterday’s gig, I asked both the Sax players if they could hear the bass ok...they were a few feet in front of me and they said ‘ooh yeagh and it sounded good with presence..the feel the same in rehearsals... it’s hard to put words to, but it seems to carry with presence ands it’s smooth...
Whilst that is just one example in one room...and in that context...it has certainly and at least opened my ears and mind to spending more time on eq
Just lastly, with regard the rumble 200
We messed today with the overdrive and different eq again with low mids cut
We both felt The 200 is quite impressive with the overdrive
I play in a 70’s gig as well and whilst I have been shy on the overdrive it seems with bass and treble at 12 o’clock with low mids rolled off, high mids around 1, might be an option. Will see how that goes in a guitar band live.
Anyway, that’s just some stuff from me, i in no way intend it as a definitive statement of what is better as such, just some thoughts from experience and I am really liking the 200 combo.
I am not sure how the rumble 200 combo would go in a full on loud aggressive drum and guitar set up, such as metal or punk but it is certainly good at what it does for me
Ps, I find the p with the tone pot rolled back seems to refine things a bit on the rumble with the contour. And all of the above is with the tweeter off. Personally I find the tweeter a bit harsh on the p, it’s not too bad on the jazz bass...
Also, the vintage button is interesting... not sure where I sit with that yet....but am certainly, in recent experience warming to the contour function...
Ross