• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Fodera Club Part XI

Status
Not open for further replies.
Curt --

BOTH Todd and I were chatting at the show together about how unless it was purely to be a "Collector's Piece" for you, this was not the right bass for you. I never want any of our players or customers to buy a bass just because it is available -- unless it is right for them. We really want to forge long-term relationships and getting someone to spend over $10k on something that they will not love is a surefire way to not have that happen...

Also, in terms of spacing, our basses are built to accommodate the bridges they will be using...everything geometrically about a 19.0mm bridged bass is slightly different from a 17.5 mm one, so swapping between the two is not a real option.

Cheers,

J

Todd,

A great many thanks for the ebony beast impressions. I think it's very clear that it's not the bass for me. I hadn't even considered the string spacing, and I'm quite sure that 19mm on a 5 string is not my bag. Of course, if I was still REALLY pondering it after your post, I'd probably ask Jason if they could swap out the 19mm for a 17.5mm bridge...I have NO IDEA how much, or if, there is a difference between the mounting holes for the two. I'm guessing that with what you had to say, the bass would be too much for me, too. and just so Jason doesn't think he lost a sale because of your 'review', I want him to know that that's not at all the case. In addition to the 'issues' with it, I simply don't have a spare $12K lying around (damn the bad luck!) Regardless, I owe you one for the help in making a decision, here. Thank you!

I loved all the pictures you took of you playing it, and the MGS. I think it's a great help to many to see the basses in the hands of an actual player, to get a better sense of the layout, size, etc. I think you did both myself, and others, a huge favor in that regard.

Lastly, I appreciate your comparison between the YYS and YYD. I guess I'm not surprised with your thoughts at all. I love your use of the language...amazing versus sublime! Outstanding! Being that I am of the over the top in terms just wanting the best of the best, I'm glad to see that you think the D is worth it to those of us who think, well, differently.
 
Sure it would work and going from E-C to B-G is fairly easy. Any reliable local shop can widen the nut slots for you. Once you have done that, however, we would need to cut you a new nut if you wanted to go back to E-C. The other point is that you will have a 33" scale B-string. Fine if you play light and understand a 33" B's inherent characteristics, but if you are looking for the tight, piano-like "Killer B," I would steer clear...

Cheers,

J

Todd. I was really trying to not love/want the MGS but i am weakening fast. I am not a huge fan of E-C so question for you and Jason when he gets home - would the MGS work OK if i decide to go B-G. the 17.5mm should not be an issue as i feel the 19MM on my emporer is at the other limit of comfort and other 5's i have owned (mm, Warwick) have been tighter...
 
Sure it would work and going from E-C to B-G is fairly easy. Any reliable local shop can widen the nut slots for you. Once you have done that, however, we would need to cut you a new nut if you wanted to go back to E-C. The other point is that you will have a 33" scale B-string. Fine if you play light and understand a 33" B's inherent characteristics, but if you are looking for the tight, piano-like "Killer B," I would steer clear...

Cheers,

J

I have switched between E-C and B-G all the time on my Imperial ... it was ordered E-C but the nut tolerated both ways without a need of making new holes...

:)
 
Given the gauge of strings we use on the MGS and how the nut is cut, I do not believe that will be the case with this bass...

Regards,

Jason

I have switched between E-C and B-G all the time on my Imperial ... it was ordered E-C but the nut tolerated both ways without a need of making new holes...

:)
 
I have used 45-125 and 32-105 sets... both worked (and the Bass came with the 28-100 set on it) - but of course the strings were laying a bit higher on the nut when I used the B-G tuning...but not that much

I only mentioned it because this way he could try it first (with a 120 B String for example) and see if he likes it or not without having the nut getting modified first and finding out later that he does not like the new tuning ;)



Given the gauge of strings we use on the MGS and how the nut is cut, I do not believe that will be the case with this bass...

Regards,

Jason
 
I love this photo from the Fodera site. Our own "nostatic" at the booth.

NAMM1253-XL.jpg
 
Sorry for my ignorance, can you Slap on this bass?

Sure. Like any bass it depends on what you're used to. 17.5mm spacing might be tight for some who prefer to slap on a bass with 19mm. Also it was set up with really low action and some guys might not prefer that. It favors a light touch. I was able to slap it but I used to play Zons with 17mm spacing so it doesn't bother me. Also the ramp is removable if you want a more traditional setup.
 
This trio will BLOW YOU AWAY. One of the very high points of my musical life last year was watching them play together. Awe inspiring...

Thanks! Hiromi is a monster on piano. Truly one of the greatest (in my opinion). She's coming back to my area (saw her last time) with Anthony Jackson in March. Can't wait for that show! :hyper:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.