• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Schpelling

Here, let me correct your sentence for you:

"Are you an English major or some sort of trouble maker?"

Should this sentence not have a comma inserted after the word, "major"?

I believe that this sentence would be more likely to be said with a pause after that word.

I believe that man never landed on the moon too. Show me proof that a comma is needed.


Well, in my mind, you are basically trying to squeeze 2 questions into one sentence.

"Are you an English major or some sort of trouble maker?"

Without the comma after "major" to indicate a pause(end of the first question), the readers instruction without it is to say the sentence straight through. The indicated pause of the comma makes it more clear that the first part of your sentence is indeed, a question.

But all of this pales in comparison to what your sentence should look like - 2 sentences. The truly correct writing of your sentence would be:

Are you an English major? Or some sort of trouble maker?

And before you say that you cannot begin a sentence with "or" - we are not writing a formal essay here. You can start a sentence with "or" for emphasis in a dialogue, especially informal, which you are doing with the sentence currently under discussion.
 
Well, in my mind, you are basically trying to squeeze 2 questions into one sentence.

"Are you an English major or some sort of trouble maker?"

Without the comma after "major" to indicate a pause(end of the first question), the readers instruction without it is to say the sentence straight through. The indicated pause of the comma makes it more clear that the first part of your sentence is indeed, a question.

But all of this pales in comparison to what your sentence should look like - 2 sentences. The truly correct writing of your sentence would be:

Are you an English major? Or some sort of trouble maker?

And before you say that you cannot begin a sentence with "or" - we are not writing a formal essay here. You can start a sentence with "or" for emphasis in a dialogue, especially informal, which you are doing with the sentence currently under discussion.

"come see the violence inherit in the system, help Im bein repressed" :help:
 
Well, in my mind, you are basically trying to squeeze 2 questions into one sentence.

"Are you an English major or some sort of trouble maker?"

Without the comma after "major" to indicate a pause(end of the first question), the readers instruction without it is to say the sentence straight through. The indicated pause of the comma makes it more clear that the first part of your sentence is indeed, a question.

But all of this pales in comparison to what your sentence should look like - 2 sentences. The truly correct writing of your sentence would be:

Are you an English major? Or some sort of trouble maker?

And before you say that you cannot begin a sentence with "or" - we are not writing a formal essay here. You can start a sentence with "or" for emphasis in a dialogue, especially informal, which you are doing with the sentence currently under discussion.


You are right. I am wrong.
 
You can scan through and find a literary mistake on just about every post. The English language is just a means of communicating.
The "it's just the Internet" excuse still doesn't make sense to me though. It's just sad to know that people have to 'try' to correctly utilize words like "there/their/they're" or "you're/your".

I just can't take fully grown adults seriously when they say "U R".

And young folk who take it further by going out of their ways to misspell a word..
DAT
ITE
DEM
 
You are right. I am wrong.

You remind me of this kid from elementary school who would trip the other kids, and then act like nothing happened.

You started a thread to complain about spelling. You then criticized another posters sentence. You then asked me to "prove it".

What happened here? You don't like it yourself? I'm not sure, but in any event, grow up.
 
You remind me of this kid from elementary school who would trip the other kids, and then act like nothing happened.

You started a thread to complain about spelling. You then criticized another posters sentence. You then asked me to "prove it".

What happened here? You don't like it yourself? I'm not sure, but in any event, grow up.

What happened was me admitting I am wrong. I'm sorry that I went about things the wrong way. I still feel that the topic was a good one but my posts were not so good.
 
What happened was me admitting I am wrong. I'm sorry that I went about things the wrong way. I still feel that the topic was a good one but my posts were not so good.

I must admit, I could have been influenced to view your response as negative, considering when my wife says, "You're right, I'm wrong." it is NEVER in a serious manner. I thought you were just blowing me off, but guess not. All good GK.
 
You remind me of this kid from elementary school who would trip the other kids, and then act like nothing happened.

You started a thread to complain about spelling. You then criticized another posters sentence. You then asked me to "prove it".

What happened here? You don't like it yourself? I'm not sure, but in any event, grow up.

GK has apologized twice. Would you like to hit or kick him one more time. Then we could tar and feather him(comma)and send him packing. WOULD THAT BE SATISFACTORY ?

;-/ Paul