Very useful infos!
I guess you can record pretty much everything with 57s. Anyways the "beginners guide" I found recommends the AKG D112 for low stuff such as bass and kickdrum, while says 57s are great for snares, toms and guitar...
If you still had to buy all the mics, would you go for 57s or these AKGs (for bass and kick)?
I had made a list in case we want to record with the Glyn Johns method
2*AKG PERCEPTION 170 (overheads)
2* Shure SM57 (one for the snares, one for the guiitar amp)
2* AKG D112 (one for the bass cab and one for the kickdrum)
Is that a good setup?
Hehehe, my personal mic collection is only two SM57s, a bullet mic, a couple of mics that have been gifted me that I don't know the names of, and the mics in my Tascam handheld recorder. But I've run sound a few times (hired gun with other's equipment), helped out in a couple of different studios for awhile, done a stupid amount of home recording, and have recorded a few records in the studio as the musician. So, I've had more time to watch folks screw with the EQ, ask questions, and listen to orders than really browse mics. However, I've spent enough time in the booth talking to the guy twiddling the knobs that knowing what you're doing with them is more important than the particular tools at hand. There's enough times that the response to "What mic are you using there?" is "Ehhh, it's an XXXX. It's not really the best for that, but we have it, and long as I do A, B, and maybe C to it, it sounds pretty nice." A is usually compression B is EQ, and C is whatever they seem to be liking that week.
So, I can't really choose mics for you. If that all makes any sense. I've seen an SM57 used for just about everything at some point. It's not what anyone would choose for a kick drum mic if they had a better kick drum mic available. So, yeah, if you are buying a mic specifically for that, buy any kick drum specific mic that you can find with a good rep and is cheaper than an SM57.
I don't have too much advice for an overhead setup. You're going over my personal experience, there. I'd probably just take the line out from my Tascam's stereo handheld mics and call it a day.
