I'm almost at my wits' end.
I've surfed the Wal fb group and gone through pages and pages of this thread.
I bought a Mk. 2 5'er this last fall, sounded amazing right out of the case, but like a dummy I changed the strings, but I did keep them. Former owner is 75% sure the original set was EBMM slinky's 45-130, so I put a new set on and was disappointed within a few days. I have tried a number of different sets and combinations (see list below). Basically, I'm trying to get as clear, piano-like tone as possible - a sound to build off of instead of one I feel I have to compensate for. The original set of strings had no colored wrapping or colored ball-ends, so I believe that eliminates some brands from the running right out of the gate if the goal was to match them. As an aside, the action is where I want it to be, battery is new and internal trimpots are untouched.
EBMM Slinky 45-130 - these possibly the closest overall but went dead way sooner than expected, and the low B wasn't as strong. The set the bass originally came with still has some zing to it. I've been usually disappointed by EB strings but this recent experience may have changed my opinion.
EBMM Cobalt single 125 / 105-45 - the single 125 Cobalt is great, just lasts forever and really, surprisingly clear. I thought the .130 cobalt single I tried was less good. The 125 was better than the original B or darn close at the least. I was less impressed by the rest of the cobalts (E-G) but am willing to accept it was a fluke package or improper installation.
DR - I've tried fat beams, DDT, lo riders and Sunbeams. On the whole they've been disappointing in the low B department and otherwise dark-sounding. Not much zing, sort of muffled.
Curt Mangan .125-.45 nickel - These too were dark as well. Not an ideal low B either. Curiously, the .105-45 sound pretty good on my Mk. 1.
Rotosound 66 125-45 - very rough on the fingers but the E-G sounded pretty good for about a week. Low B is definitely not their speciality, though.
Any guidance is aappreciated. Thanks for letting me rant.
View attachment 4964208