Hey old friends ...Oh My ....a funny thing happened while I was at Bass San Diego today! I was there to check out Bergantino CN212 cabs and the new GK MB Fusion 800. Had a wonderful time with my Nordy VJ5C checking out the cab and comparing amps. Then an F Bass BN5 with Maccassar Ebony FB caught my eye. Plugged it in.
OH My GOD!! got the attention of my talkbass friend Capt Wally who was there lending a second set of ears. We both felt the tone of the F Bass KILLED everything. I played and executed better on this bass. It had a ramp between PU's and that was my first time playing with a Ramp. LOVED it! ..
Soooo... I put $$ on it! They didn't have an Ash/Maple BN5 to compare, but this bass had punch, growl, KILLER/amazing slap tone, Burpy Jaco growl from the Bridge PU and it played like a dream! Should I hold out for Ash/Maple or finish and follow through in bringing this bass home?
Gary! I suppose this means I have to send you an Fbass strap now!
Yes, finger ramps are wonderful, aren't they? I DEFINITELY prefer them. They allow me to play with much more freedom, whereas without ramps I find myself playing with my right hand over one of the pickups.
As for the ash+maple vs. ash+ebony...
I have an ash and maple BN5 and I love it and will no doubt be buried with it...
But I ADORE ash + ebony. That's what I have on my BN6 (and of course my 2 AC6s).
Ebony is much more rare on BN5s than on BN6s, which makes that bass you are considering cooler in my opinion.
But the ebony is a fantastic fit with the ash body and 60s pickup positions.
I had a Fodera Yin Yang for years with an alder body and maple finger board which I loved for fingerstyle playing, but disliked for slapping -- which is very ironic when you consider that it is Victor Wooten's signature bass. But the slap tone was just too clacky for me.
Not long after I sold my Yin Yang, I noticed Victor Wooten stopped playing his maple board YY and started playing one with an EBONY finger board.
[Invalid or Expired Link Removed].
Roger rates finger board wood from brightest to warmest like this:
Maple (brightest)
Ebony
Morado (a.k.a. Pau Ferro)
Madagascar Rosewood
Amazon Rosewood
Brazilian Rosewood (warmest)
In this article, Roger writes that maple is "best for slap." That may be true if you are talking about a 4 string bass with an ash body, and play like Marcus Miller.
Interestingly, Roger also wrote, "
EBONY: Not as bright as maple.
Most immediate attack and punch of all our fingerboard woods.
Note is more fundamental with less overtones. Best for fretless. Pure black ebony from Madagascar is limited. African ebony has some grey mottling but is still very beautiful."
That totally squares with my personal experience. While I LOVED my maple boarded Yin Yang for finger style playing, I could not make myself like its slap tone. Using modern slapping and plucking styles, it was just too clacky -- too percussive and not enough fundamental.
It tried every kind of string I could come into to improve that bass's slap tone and never found a string that helped, so I resigned myself to playing that bass for times when I'm not slapping. The problem was, I pretty much never play a 4 string bass, much less play a 4 string bass I can't slap, so I sold that bass.
Then I saw something interesting.
Victor Wooten, whose main bass was a perfectly fine alder and maple Yin Yang... suddenly started playing a Yin Yang with an EBONY board instead.
As Roger Sadowsky said, ebony has the quickest attack and the most fundamental, so if you are Victor Wooten and can slap and pop 10,000 notes per second, an ebony board is going to let us hear more of the note and less of the clacking than a maple board would. Plus, the brightness of the maple board brings out that sharp fret attack sound.
BTW, 10,000 notes per second was NOT my problem on the Yin Yang or any other bass.
So I can totally see why you would like an ebony board on a BN5.
And of course ebony is very nice for fretless, so when you dial up a Jaco sound, you are going to get a wonderful tone there too.
I say you have a rare find that is probably a great price compared to new, and you shouldn't let it get away.
128. olegsulimov -
BN5 NYC,
AC6
129. Slammyapple -
BN5
130. jephil -
BNF5, BN6
131. MVPBASS -
BN4,
BN4,
BN4
132. lindseyp -
BN5
133. J.Wolf -
BN5,
AC6
134. Karelbass -
VF4,
BN4 32.5",
VF5
135. uilleann13 -
BN6
136. GRoberts - BN5