Not to derail this thread from Gibson bashing/Fender bashing, but I just saw a cool short scale SG today. I know its not a new model, but it had a natural finish and the body was a thick maple top over (I guess) mohogany...a combo I haven't seen before.
It was really, really nice. I'm not a short scale or four string guy, but if I had an extra grand lying around I think I would have bought it. Felt like it was about 7.5 pounds, the neck shape was real comfy, quality looked good, sounded good--really growly out of the bridge. I was impressed with it.
Honestly, from first impressions, if I had to pick between a 08 American J, P or one of these...I don't know, I might pick this.