• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Things that are Metal...and things that aren't

Justin Beiber is metal?:eyebrow:

yes, he is metal, the truth about justin bieber is not that he is a person that makes watered-down pop music. He is a robot made by some massive record label, solely for the purpose of getting 13 year old girls off, to distract them from the fact that they're buying watered-down pop music. And robots are metal -very metal.

edit: sorry for the double post, but I don't know how to put two quotes into one post.
 
I for one look forward to complaining about how this new crap isn't as good as it was when it comes to metal I love being a cantankerous PITA, but IMO metal is the only genre where the new is as good and sometimes better than the old. Same cannot be said for my other favorites, espescially country (again, IMO. If you prefer Rascall Flatts to Merle Haggard thats...hell I can't say it.)

And I'd be on the opposite end of the spectrum.

I used to love me some metal! I grew up loving bands like Sepultura, Pantera, Morbid Angel, Cannibal Corpse, Testament, Napalm Death. I got to a certain point where I branched out in my musical interests (from not just listening to aggressive anymore), and I can't really get into ANY metal these days.

I would agree, that probably the technical boundaries are pushed more nowadays than maybe the things I grew up listening to on Headbangers Ball in the early 90's, but meh. Maybe I got old. Maybe metal got old. Maybe both.

As opposed to other genres though, metal never seemed to progress beyond a new variation of dropped tuning, or screamed vocals. IMO, it's all been done before.

Metal checklist:
Blast beats or no?
Dropped D or C tuning?
Screaming the verse and singing the chorus, or vice versa? Scream both?
One solo? Two solos? Dueling solos?

Just my opinion for what it's worth...
 
Not Metal:
A brown corduroy blazer

JimmyPage.jpg


Jimmy Page, far left.
 
And I'd be on the opposite end of the spectrum.

I used to love me some metal! I grew up loving bands like Sepultura, Pantera, Morbid Angel, Cannibal Corpse, Testament, Napalm Death. I got to a certain point where I branched out in my musical interests (from not just listening to aggressive anymore), and I can't really get into ANY metal these days.

I would agree, that probably the technical boundaries are pushed more nowadays than maybe the things I grew up listening to on Headbangers Ball in the early 90's, but meh. Maybe I got old. Maybe metal got old. Maybe both.

As opposed to other genres though, metal never seemed to progress beyond a new variation of dropped tuning, or screamed vocals. IMO, it's all been done before.

Metal checklist:
Blast beats or no?
Dropped D or C tuning?
Screaming the verse and singing the chorus, or vice versa? Scream both?
One solo? Two solos? Dueling solos?

Just my opinion for what it's worth...

There is a fair amount of crappy new metal (IMO) but there was some older stuff I didn't care much for either. I will agree that as the genre has gotten more popular and branched out into all sorts of little sub genres, a good deal of what is rolled up in the "metal" catagory is utter junk.
 
Metal:
  • Anything medieval
  • Blood
  • Death
  • Beastiality
  • Polytheistic Religions
  • Fire
  • Unintelligile Vocals
  • Bones
  • Corpses
  • Hatred
  • Not being liked
  • Not liking institutions
  • Insanity
  • Killing band members
  • Guitars with 7+ Strings
  • Basses with 5+ Strings
  • Lack of Understanding of Music
  • Unknown Symbols

Not metal:
  • Music
  • Sanity
  • Kindness
  • Music
  • Goodness
  • Monotheistic Religion
  • Life
  • Music
  • Intelligible Vocals
  • Suboridnance
  • Music
  • Liking anything
  • Liking other bands
  • Drum machines
  • Music
  • 4-String basses
  • 6-String Guitars
  • Acoustic Guitars
  • Tambourines
  • Understanding Music
  • Music
Disclaimer: The "music" is a JOKE! Don't get bent out of shape over it.