I will go one better. I like this strap.
LM Products Odin Viking Series Leather Strap - Black
2 1/2 ", not padded, thick leather. Seems like it shouldn't be comfortable, but is perhaps the most comfortable strap I have. (I have a second that gets used with the JC).
Someone- I think you- had mentioned these recently. I'm seriously considering either a Viking or a Valkyrie.