What about surf green/maple?
Also been considering natural but worried it may look a bit boring after the initial honeymoon.
That would look killer. There is a guy who posts over on the Nordstrand thread who has that color combination for his Nordy, and it is just beautiful. I would thing a poly Surf Green (if there is that option) with a gloss maple neck and no matching headstock would look great, and also be quite affordable.