• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Request - ease up on the Sire advocacy

Status
Not open for further replies.
As a lover of all things FrankenBass/Partscaster, I feel kinda like that weird Mopar guy in the middle of the Chevy vs. Ford wars. In fact that was me in high school--- lover of the funky Torqueflite Transmission tied to a 426 Hemi or a 340 wedge, when all around me were Hurst and Muncey Transmissions tied to 350's and 427's. Just never really was a brand name guy I guess.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nobody
As a lover of all things FrankenBass/Partscaster, I feel kinda like that weird Mopar guy in the middle of the Chevy vs. Ford wars. In fact that was me in high school--- lover of the funky Torqueflite Transmission tied to a 426 Hemi or a 340 wedge, when all around me were Hurst and Muncey Transmissions tied to 350's and 427's. Just never really was a brand name guy I guess.
I can relate. But you wouldn't drop by every Shelby Cobra thread to tell everyone how awesome your Chevy Nova is I'm hoping.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Berniez40
As a lover of all things FrankenBass/Partscaster, I feel kinda like that weird Mopar guy in the middle of the Chevy vs. Ford wars. In fact that was me in high school--- lover of the funky Torqueflite Transmission tied to a 426 Hemi or a 340 wedge, when all around me were Hurst and Muncey Transmissions tied to 350's and 427's. Just never really was a brand name guy I guess.

Pontiacs Baby!

I mean where do you think a name like TinIndian comes from anyway!
 
And how, pray tell, am I supposed to try one when the only option I have to try one is to drop half a grand and order one?
You're starting to sound like GNL2000. After he recently cancelled his Sire order, he suggested that someone buy a Sire and have it shipped to him if "you really want to prove how wrong I am about Sire". You might want to ask if he had any takers. Maybe they'll send you one too.
I didn't speculate about anything . . .
I'm not sure if you didn't notice my previous question, or if you are just ignoring it. Not that you have any obligation to answer.
Just curious, if someone on here questions the quality of your basses, without actually having owned or even played one, should we believe them? If they say they can tell, just by looking at some pictures, that your basses couldn't possibly be as good as Brand B, should we take their word for it? Or should we give more credence to the comments of someone who owns, or has played, one of your basses and also owns, or has played, Brand B?
I know you have a great reputation as a skilled builder and luthier and I've enjoyed reading your posts over at the Luthier's Corner. I have to say I've found some of your posts on this thread to be rather disconcerting, as well as unnecessary, to say the least.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KickingBass
I honestly do not know what a sire is.
I see it mentioned alot but never looked it up....Sue me.
Oh, that's a very pragmatic approach to the subject!
I can play Flight of The Bumble Bee at 350 BPM. And I do it on a Sire. I can only play it at 175BPM on a Fender American Deluxe. You explain that, mister.
I can play that song in 450 bpm on a jigsaw but i can't play it on my american standard jazz bass at all!
Consider yourself sued.
Oh, that was a ridiculously pragmatic response to the post above!
 
Oh, that's a very pragmatic approach to the subject!

I can play that song in 450 bpm on a jigsaw but i can't play it on my american standard jazz bass at all!

Oh, that was a ridiculously pragmatic response to the post above!
I was being honest.
I practice at home alone and have collector derived interest in instruments.
Both guitar and bass.
Most recently bass so I was being honest in my ignorance as to sire....sorry
 
I can relate. But you wouldn't drop by every Shelby Cobra thread to tell everyone how awesome your Chevy Nova is I'm hoping.
Yeah, as a Mopar (Chrysler Dodge Plymouth) Lover, I doubt I would tout the wonders of a Chevy Nova under any circumstances. I do, however see your point. Lots of patronizing going on in The Sire Department. Never played one myself. I was disappointed to see that the 5 String is only a 34" scale. Not that that should matter too much for most folks, but my Low "B" is always drop tuned to a low "A", so I need a 35" minimum scale...Thus the FrankenBasses.....even my uprights are Frankenbasses/Partscasters. Now I might put a fully blown RoadRunner up against that Cobra.....but that's a different thread altogether.
 
Honestly every time I saw a marcus Miller reference. And sire marcus Miller.
I assumed that it was referring to the fender marcus Miller....I am sorry.
No need to be sorry. A big reason that guys are hyping the Sires on here. Since you can't walk into GC or Sam ash, or what ever your favorite MI store and expect to see one, so word of mouth has been the best way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.